ricktoronto said:
For the umpteenth time, while you might think that this is a tip, it isn't, in fact it may be looked upon disdainfully as implying a degree of poverty , which while true, doesn't need to be pointed out to someone making $3 -5 a day.
Cash (in the US$2 a day range, or RD$100 a day) is a tip.
If these items were partially used or supplied by the hotel in the room, then they are even more inappropriate, in lieu of cash.
There are several good threads on appropriate tipping behaviour but the best and only true gratuity is cash, ideally given to the maid in person each day or periodically. Same with waiters and hostesses even though you are eating and drinking for "free" (you aren't - you paid in advance - so tip accordingly).
I note your comments and I would like to advise that having researched appropriate tipping before we departed, we tipped (regularly with US$) our maid, the waiters/hostesses and other hotel staff.
In addtion, we took school supplies which we handed in at a local school we visited during an organised trip - these were much needed and appreciated by the head teacher!! I think this is far more appropriate than the actions of some of the American tourists on our excursion who were making the kids beg/sing/dance for money!!!
We left several quality UK brand products at the end of our stay (not hotel products). These were not left in lieu of cash but in addition to, and it was entirely up to our maid whether she kept these or binned them.
As for partially used products - the traders on the beach frequently requested we bring such items and would ask for the clothing/shoes you were wearing in exchange for their goods. They approached us not the other way round!! When I asked one trader what he could possibly want with a half empty bottle of perfume, he replied that it would be a gift for his wife.
In researching the DR before our trip I did come across several threads on this site (and others) which suggested taking things such as toiletries and clothing - especially in the aftermath of the hurricane season.