Getting ripped off in mid air!!

Chavela

New member
Feb 29, 2008
14
0
0
My mother recently visited the DR on a mission to do some investagatory work for our non-profit. She also happens to be a dog lover. She rescued a street dog in Samana and got it all it's shots, spayed and neutered. Then she wanted to get the dog-her- a home. She decided that she wanted to got to St. Croix to get the dog a home. She went ahead and rented a charter that AIRDOMCA told her would be 1,000.00 plus tax. I thought that was excessive, but it was meant to save her the hassel of driving back to Santa Domingo and taking a traditional flight. She was delayed 6 hours because of home land security strip search of the plane, and interrogation of the pilots and my mother. A nightmare. Wait, it gets better-or worse. When my mom returned to the states my dad opened the credit card bill and "Carribair" had charged them $11,000.00 for the flight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! They had rushed her to sign the fax and she was unfamilar with the peso conversion. She's 65 years old and her eyes aren't that great. What can we do??!!! Please let me know her credit card company is disputing it with her. Carribair is blaming the guy Lennin at Aerodomca for telling my mom the wrong price for the plane, and saying that the 11,000.00 is the right price. Please help!!! Thank You!!
 

scrubmuncher

On Vacation!
Jul 6, 2007
171
10
0
Wow, that's a pretty serious mistake to make. If your mother has put her signature to anything with the price on it then I doubt you will beable to do much. Her eyesight is no concern of the agents really. Bloody nasty story, hope someone can point you in the right direction.
 

dringa

New member
Oct 17, 2004
223
6
0
Chavela - Sorry to hear this has happened to you and your mother. Here is some remedies that might be possible. I am a pilot and have flown from Samana. Call Aerodomca / SAP and ACSA - these are the current 3 operators that can provide you service right now. Get a quote for the same flight in writing. Ask them for a charter from Samana to St. Croix. Have them send it to you in writing or via e-mail. Depending on the aircraft they use, it should be around US$3000. This is about a 1 hour flight in each direction - so for them to do this flight, they will charge you 2 hours - which will bring the plane home back to SDQ. Once you have these quotes, send them to your credit card company and see if they can use these quotes to get your money back. Unfortunately, due to Caribair being shut down - they are really drained and it might take also some legal advise from a lawyer in Santo Domingo to persue this credit. I hope the above helps in some way. Sorry to hear about your problem
 

Lambada

Gold
Mar 4, 2004
9,478
410
0
80
www.ginniebedggood.com
dringa, would US$3000 be the approx price for a shared charter, or one just for one person plus dog? Or does it make no difference? I'm assuming price will have something to do with number of seats sold?
 

hammerdown

Bronze
Apr 29, 2005
1,466
107
63
have her contact the credit card company and refuse to pay, and dispute the charge....the card company will not pay the airline company if she refuses to pay....and no it will not affect her standing with them....but she has to act soon, real soon....the card company will do an investigation and let her know of the results....but she has to be firm on the refusal to pay the total....trust me it works
 

dringa

New member
Oct 17, 2004
223
6
0
Lambada - a charter is a charter - you are renting the plane - its not based on seats - you can have one person on board or a full load -the per hour cost really dont change in that situation
 
May 5, 2007
9,246
92
0
I'm confused as to where the charter originated and ended. She mentions Homeland Security? Did thsi flight land in USA?

$1,000.00 bucks isn't going to charter much, maybe a Cessna 182 for a couple hundred mile round trip
 

Tamborista

hasta la tambora
Apr 4, 2005
11,747
1,343
113
I'm confused as to where the charter originated and ended. She mentions Homeland Security? Did thsi flight land in USA?

$1,000.00 bucks isn't going to charter much, maybe a Cessna 182 for a couple hundred mile round trip

St. Croix is the USVI Miss Smarty Pants!
 

scrubmuncher

On Vacation!
Jul 6, 2007
171
10
0
I'm confused as to where the charter originated and ended. She mentions Homeland Security? Did thsi flight land in USA?

$1,000.00 bucks isn't going to charter much, maybe a Cessna 182 for a couple hundred mile round trip

I think the point is his mum is a little bad with her eyesight and misread the price, or misheard the quote, or the guy took advantage.
 

CFA123

Silver
May 29, 2004
3,512
413
83
She rescued a street dog in Samana ... She decided that she wanted to got to St. Croix to get the dog a home... She went ahead and rented a charter...

Pure silliness. And as board members we laugh at the lengths people will go to spending money on their Dominican girlfriend or boyfriend! But then again, I guess mum screwed the pooch, too... figuratively, not literally. ;)
 
May 5, 2007
9,246
92
0
Thank you Ma'am

St. Croix is the USVI Miss Smarty Pants!


Well Ma'am, I honestly overlooked that and I feel so silly for your highness having to point this out

Thank you for spending your life monitoring this board and correcting we silly newbies

Now in your educated opinion, based on your thousands of hours PIC and or Charter contracts, is that a fair price for the charter of an airplane you obviously know the type of, we mere mortals have to ask questions to provide a valid answer.

The OP said something about rescuing the dog in Samana and wanting to save the hassle of returning to Santo Domingo and wanting to go to St Croix and when returning tot he USA< I really have no idea where the flight originated and terminated, but I'm sure Tamborisa does, so if you could enlighten me I would appreciate it
 
Last edited:
May 5, 2007
9,246
92
0
I think the point is his mum is a little bad with her eyesight and misread the price, or misheard the quote, or the guy took advantage.

One would definitely need to know the type of craft chartered. A small Gates Lear from Boston to DC and return , about the same 650-700 mile R/T could easily run 10 grand, a King Air maybe 6-7 thousand

I'm sure Cobraboy could give you a close cost estimate.

I have flown very little in Caribbean so don't know the route, don't know if a single would meet ETOPS, there was mention of "pilots" (Plural) so I assuming something in at least cabin class, not inexpensive and I guess anyone chartering on a whim would be somewhat familiar with costs?

I do agree changing of the contract would leave options to dispute the charges
 

scrubmuncher

On Vacation!
Jul 6, 2007
171
10
0
I think I got the wrong end of the stick and have decided I know nothing of prices regarding this kind of transportation, I shall look and keep my gob shut as I feel I this could be a very self deserving error and bank hit.
 

Lambada

Gold
Mar 4, 2004
9,478
410
0
80
www.ginniebedggood.com
Lambada - a charter is a charter - you are renting the plane - its not based on seats - you can have one person on board or a full load -the per hour cost really dont change in that situation

Yes I understand (I'm a pilot too, but only private, not commercial) but I thought that around the islands some companies operated a system of 'shared' private charters i.e. a bunch of strangers could go on same trip if it met their needs (like a shared consignment deal on a container), thus reducing costs.

Chavela, I'm 65 too & my eyesight isn't that great (but it was good enough to get me my pilot's licence many years ago) but common sense dictates that US$1000 for a private charter would only cover a very short distance (as dringa says, charterer pays for return to home base as a deadhead - empty leg). There are companies that sell 'empty legs' at a reduced price.

For those asking about per hour costs, my guess would be something like US$1300 per hour for a King Air (turbo prop), US$2500 per hour for a small Citation or Learjet, US$4500 per hour for the medium sized Gulfstream & maybe US$8000 per hour for a large Gulfstream; & the 'cheapies' approx US$600 per hour for a Cessna 182 & maybe US$800 for an Islander (all including pilots, obviously :cheeky:). I'm sure cobraboy has more exact figures.
 

cobraboy

Pro-Bono Demolition Hobbyist
Jul 24, 2004
40,964
936
113
Yes I understand (I'm a pilot too, but only private, not commercial) but I thought that around the islands some companies operated a system of 'shared' private charters i.e. a bunch of strangers could go on same trip if it met their needs (like a shared consignment deal on a container), thus reducing costs.

Chavela, I'm 65 too & my eyesight isn't that great (but it was good enough to get me my pilot's licence many years ago) but common sense dictates that US$1000 for a private charter would only cover a very short distance (as dringa says, charterer pays for return to home base as a deadhead - empty leg). There are companies that sell 'empty legs' at a reduced price.

For those asking about per hour costs, my guess would be something like US$1300 per hour for a King Air (turbo prop), US$2500 per hour for a small Citation or Learjet, US$4500 per hour for the medium sized Gulfstream & maybe US$8000 per hour for a large Gulfstream; & the 'cheapies' approx US$600 per hour for a Cessna 182 & maybe US$800 for an Islander (all including pilots, obviously :cheeky:). I'm sure cobraboy has more exact figures.
^^^All fairly accurate, although a Commercial Cessna 182 would be around $300 per hour, a Seneca maybe $500 hr.

At the FBO, we got calls all the time saying:

Potential Customer: The airlines want $1200 to fly to NYC First Class and returning the next day. That's too much. How much for a charter?

Me: What kind of plane? Lear 31? Lear 35? C3? Challenger 601? Jet? Prop? Turboprop?

Them: A little, cheap one. A jet.

Me: That would be $18,000, plus $1500 overnight fee.

Them: No, no...one of those little, cheap jets.

Me: That is a little, cheap one. 8 seats.

Them: :surprised
 
  • Like
Reactions: MikeFisher

MikeFisher

The Fisherman/Weather Mod
Feb 28, 2006
13,771
2,206
113
Punta Cana/DR
www.mikefisher.fun
absolutely right.
if she understood 1K and got charged 11K's i would guess the misunderstanding been that the charter flight would cost 10K's plus 1K extra to let that dog on board. that rate is depending of planetype absolutely not out of the rates range for comfo private flight charters between islands down here. if you want a really comfo one you pay much more.
Mike
 

joyterrell1

New member
Feb 18, 2008
46
0
0
Thanks

have her contact the credit card company and refuse to pay, and dispute the charge....the card company will not pay the airline company if she refuses to pay....and no it will not affect her standing with them....but she has to act soon, real soon....the card company will do an investigation and let her know of the results....but she has to be firm on the refusal to pay the total....trust me it works

The credit card company already paid the Caribair guy. Can she still refuse to pay, send in the other quotes that we get and have a chance--thanks!!
 

joyterrell1

New member
Feb 18, 2008
46
0
0
Thanks!!!

Chavela - Sorry to hear this has happened to you and your mother. Here is some remedies that might be possible. I am a pilot and have flown from Samana. Call Aerodomca / SAP and ACSA - these are the current 3 operators that can provide you service right now. Get a quote for the same flight in writing. Ask them for a charter from Samana to St. Croix. Have them send it to you in writing or via e-mail. Depending on the aircraft they use, it should be around US$3000. This is about a 1 hour flight in each direction - so for them to do this flight, they will charge you 2 hours - which will bring the plane home back to SDQ. Once you have these quotes, send them to your credit card company and see if they can use these quotes to get your money back. Unfortunately, due to Caribair being shut down - they are really drained and it might take also some legal advise from a lawyer in Santo Domingo to persue this credit. I hope the above helps in some way. Sorry to hear about your problem

The credit card company already paid the Caribair guy. Can she still refuse to pay, send in the other quotes that we get and have a chance--thanks!!
 

MikeFisher

The Fisherman/Weather Mod
Feb 28, 2006
13,771
2,206
113
Punta Cana/DR
www.mikefisher.fun
claims can be made after a 'false' voucher been paid.
but with what legal proof you want to claim that she get's money back?
she signed the form, that means she agreed to the charter rate which i do not see that overdone on the market, so she made a deal, purchased a product, got that purchased product completely and without any failure delivered, why should the seller not get paid?
if i sell you one of my own businesse's charters for 2K's and a month later you hear from a former customer that he got a 'similar' charter on a 'similar' outfitter for just 1.200, would that mean in your opinion you have the right to get something back?
basically it is a buyer who get's the offer of a seller for a specific product, buyer agrees, seller provides service, deal.
Mike