Yes, I am sorry, I certainly understand that and if these girls were in school I would not have mentioned it. That would not have been anything to me except for working for lodging. But these are Haitian girls who are not enrolled in school. They are mostly in Pedernales. They are fed. They are housed. They are given clothes. The Dominican NGO worker that told me about it has arguements with them because there is a group of the women who are doing it.. quite a lot of them, and they are leaders of the women's community.. and he keeps saying that they must be sent to school. Which, of course, would cost the Dominicans money.. They say that room and board is enough. Raphael, we will call him.. says, no, it is slavery...
so .. yes, I understand sending a girl to work for room and board while going to school but Haitians cannot go to public school for free. If the family is paying for school.. then, the girl is being paid. She is being educated! That is great. That is something.
It is just a question of really seeing what is an advantage.
Like I really do not think that it is any advantage at all the help that is being given here to the Haitian mothers to give birth .. because really , they are too uneducated themselves to understand the consequences for their children here. In Haiti, MOST people do not have papers. Here MOST people DO. So the Dominicans think they are helping by giving medical care when in fact they are often depriving the child of statehood.. OK not always. The great majority of mothers just give birth and used to go back. But who knows. Things got much worse after the quake. Bad cases are transported from the border to the Capital.
This may be just a small thing. I have seen the hospitals and did a story on it and the Haitian mothers are not treated differently than Dominicans. And certainly the women on the border are poor enough themselves so maybe just givng room and board is enough.
But I do wonder really how it is that there are so many Haitian vendors about, no one checks., no license nothing. They just set up shop. Well ok. New construction. Completely Haitian crews.. no checks. And then there are complaints about the Haitians here. Well.. what do Dominicans expect? If you can come in and get set up with a business (I assume that a Dominican sets them up with the carts and stuff) or get a job or whatever? Why is it the Haitians fault? If the border barriers are let down and anyone and everyone can walk right in, why is it the HAitians fault if they walk in? Why are the Dominicans constantly crying out against the government of Haiti or the people of Haiti instead of against their OWN government?
so .. yes, I understand sending a girl to work for room and board while going to school but Haitians cannot go to public school for free. If the family is paying for school.. then, the girl is being paid. She is being educated! That is great. That is something.
It is just a question of really seeing what is an advantage.
Like I really do not think that it is any advantage at all the help that is being given here to the Haitian mothers to give birth .. because really , they are too uneducated themselves to understand the consequences for their children here. In Haiti, MOST people do not have papers. Here MOST people DO. So the Dominicans think they are helping by giving medical care when in fact they are often depriving the child of statehood.. OK not always. The great majority of mothers just give birth and used to go back. But who knows. Things got much worse after the quake. Bad cases are transported from the border to the Capital.
This may be just a small thing. I have seen the hospitals and did a story on it and the Haitian mothers are not treated differently than Dominicans. And certainly the women on the border are poor enough themselves so maybe just givng room and board is enough.
But I do wonder really how it is that there are so many Haitian vendors about, no one checks., no license nothing. They just set up shop. Well ok. New construction. Completely Haitian crews.. no checks. And then there are complaints about the Haitians here. Well.. what do Dominicans expect? If you can come in and get set up with a business (I assume that a Dominican sets them up with the carts and stuff) or get a job or whatever? Why is it the Haitians fault? If the border barriers are let down and anyone and everyone can walk right in, why is it the HAitians fault if they walk in? Why are the Dominicans constantly crying out against the government of Haiti or the people of Haiti instead of against their OWN government?