That's the point. They want to clean it up. Most of the businesses that suffer or foreign owned and from the viewpoint of those that pay the police, these businesses are part of the problem of preventing the town from having a nice upscale international reputation. Remember, face is everything.
Upscale tourists do not generally want to mix with the local poor people, riff-raff, or get robbed. They don't CARE if the tourists go away. That's not the kind of tourist they want. The kind going away were embarassing the govt. So who is pulling the strings. Who are "They?"
From what I've seen over the years, business owners and clients alike have pulled hairs trying to figure that one out. Nobody really seems to know. Suspects have been the big all-inclusives, the church, the police captain, the newspapers, ... I even heard once it was the wife of a judge that got annoyed when she caught her husband with a young local girl.
A handful of the very popular businesses just didn't pay attention to the system and tried to play it by the book. They forgot to spread the wealth through the informal system that existed before they arrived and for that, they got no favors. You get what you pay for.
They also forgot about image. Image is a big deal in the Dominican Republic. They allowed people to show up wearing the same smelly t-shirt and shorts they had on all day at the beach. It really put on a bad image and the papers had a field day making the places look like scum.
You must note that for instance in Boca Chica, the disco at the Hamaca, touted as a 5-star hotel, open to the public and having the very same people from the street, is doing fine. They have a dress code. Hell, they have an "appearance" code. And the management takes an active role in seeing that no crap goes on inside. No pick-pocketing or fighting. Tuxedo wearing staff. Upscale. Stuffy if you like, but upscale none the less.
The local businesses must take part of the responsibilty for what is happening. Change is in the wind. Sosua will turn around, just as Boca Chica is being rebuilt and redefined. Some of those failing businesses really aren't doing that town much justice and the ones that are will just have to weather the change.
When who is in charge is not clear, this is what you get. Who can businesses complain to? Some of the business owners thing the local girls are the problem. Some think the police. Some think the big all-inclusives are to blame.
What about the police coming in tearing down businesses. Literally, with chain saws and ropes. No court hearing. Just a command from a boss, no notice. I've seen it.
What about military coming in and confiscating hotel furniture, CONTRARY to the result of a judicial hearing? What about the most legit of businesses being shaken down while the darkest operations go untouched?
What about fabrications in the newspapers, tarnishing for years, the reputation of the towns?
I've seen authority flex their muscle from time to time. It isn't pretty and it isn't fair. It isn't even legal. So? Little by little though things are starting to become "Americanized" so to speak. Businesses that don't pay their taxes or don't have the right papers are being shut down, ...
One new disco right outside Boca Chica doesn't even allow SMOKING inside. This from an area where trash is regularly burned on the side of the road. Go figure. Just like the no-cell-phone-while-driving law gets put into place and enforced yet a huge chunk of drivers don't even have safe vehicles or proper insurance.
At the very least, the night crowds have been reduced to a size that can be effectively monitored by the handful of police. Many locals have been scared away or intimidated away. Many tourists have declared the area to suck for what they came for. And in their place, new people are already trickling in, people that don't know what the place was like before and like it just fine the way it is. I must admit, I haven't seen a fight in the street in a while. I used to seem the regularly, usually about 3:15am as drunk tourists got carried awa.
Major renovations began in Boca Chica a couple years ago and I think the same will happen to Sosua. Not overnight, but the government has still not settled on what the DR is going to be. Upscale or value. All-inclusive or small-business. A mix with the locals or rather gated. Straight up or wild-west. Singles or family. Planned or everybody for themself.
These towns will not stay empty. Someone will always come in where someone else failed.
What, you want fair? In a country where if they can't get the culprit, they arrest their family and hold them until they do get their culprit? In a country where people are held in jails for years without ever having their case put in front of a judge? In a country where you can be held without the possibility of bail on simple drug posession charges? In a country where even basic food and water is not given to local short-term detainees?
The Dominican Republic is NOT as safe as people on this board make it out to be, especially in the tourist towns. Violent crime is rare, but theft is WAY common. Mostly pick-pockets, jewelry grabbers, and people taking things from rooms, some theives being invited guests, some not. In the lower circles, it is even common for people to get things stolen from their houses when nobody has been there besides family and good friends. Not big stuff, but stealing none the less.
People are generally safe, property is not.
This is the Dominican Republic in towns like Boca Chica and Sosua. This is why I do not advise anybody to buy. Rent instead. What comes around goes around. One things for sure, if you don't like today, come back tomorrow. Things are always changing. I've seen it worse and I've seen it better.
Fair? Ha ha ha. Where do you think you are?
Police arrest unfairly? Talk to some people of the Trujillo days. Now those police took care of business, personally.