UN experts urge Dominican Republic to protect women's rights

islandhopping

New member
Nov 11, 2014
208
0
0
27 July 2016 ? Expressing serious concern over the proposed penal code amendment that would criminalize abortions, United Nations human rights experts today urged the Dominican Republic's President and legislators to protect women's rights to sexual and reproductive health in the Caribbean country.

?We urge Dominican authorities to repeal all restrictive legal provisions regarding abortion, especially in cases of risk to the health, including mental health, of the woman or girl, of rape and incest and of fatal impairment of the foetus,? they stressed in a press release.

The experts' call comes at a time when the Dominican Senate will debate the reform of the Penal Code, which was adopted by the Chamber of Deputies and promulgated by the President in 2014. The code partially decriminalized the access to abortion services under three circumstances, including when the life of a pregnant women or girl was at risk, when the foetus could not survive outside the womb and when the pregnancy resulted from rape or incest.

The proposed text of the Criminal Code establishes that women who induce the termination of their pregnancy will be liable to two to three year-imprisonment sentences. Health professionals who perform abortions under any circumstances other than risk to the pregnant woman or girl's life will be liable to four to 10 years in jail. Under the proposed amendment, terminating a pregnancy is only available in one case: when there is a risk for the life of the pregnant woman or girl.

?In comparison with the text of the Criminal Code adopted in 2014, the new proposal to amend the Dominican Criminal Code constitutes a clear regression in women's and girls' rights, especially to access safe healthcare services,? the experts said.

?Reducing access to such health services violates women's and girls' right to be protected against gender-based discrimination and from torture and ill-treatment,? they said.

?The Dominican Republic did not seize this key moment of legislative amendment to reaffirm its commitment towards the elimination of gender discrimination in its legislation and to advance women's and adolescents' sexual and reproductive rights but, rather, is attempting to remove crucial rights to reproductive health,? the experts deplored.

They urged President Danilo Medina and its government to take all necessary measures in accordance with their international human rights obligations, to ensure that women and girls have effective and safe access to all necessary healthcare services, including sexual and reproductive services.

http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=54571
 

bob saunders

Platinum
Jan 1, 2002
32,568
5,984
113
dr1.com
Abortion = reproductive health???????? I don't agree with the DR absolute ban on abortion but to call abortion reproductive heath is ridiculous.
Reproductive control, perhaps.
 

drSix

Silver
Oct 13, 2013
1,323
0
36
Post deleted by moderator : Don't bring religion into the regular forums
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Ecoman1949

Born to Ride.
Oct 17, 2015
2,807
1,311
113
Abortion = reproductive health???????? I don't agree with the DR absolute ban on abortion but to call abortion reproductive heath is ridiculous.
Reproductive control, perhaps.

Bob,
I think the reproductive health inference is directed mainly at the mental aspects of unwanted pregnancies, pregnancies caused by sexual assault, and pregnancies where the woman is carrying a child with severe physical and mental disabilities. Abortion is not accepted by all peoples and cultures, but you have to admit that the results of no abortion access are much worse in a country like the DR. The selling of young girls for prostitution, overpopulation, destitute children born into an endless cycle of poverty, etc. Many countries use pregnancy prevention education and abortion to control the population. India and China are two examples. Abortion may be perceived as an evil but it is a necessary evil in some countries.
 

bob saunders

Platinum
Jan 1, 2002
32,568
5,984
113
dr1.com
Bob,
I think the reproductive health inference is directed mainly at the mental aspects of unwanted pregnancies, pregnancies caused by sexual assault, and pregnancies where the woman is carrying a child with severe physical and mental disabilities. Abortion is not accepted by all peoples and cultures, but you have to admit that the results of no abortion access are much worse in a country like the DR. The selling of young girls for prostitution, overpopulation, destitute children born into an endless cycle of poverty, etc. Many countries use pregnancy prevention education and abortion to control the population. India and China are two examples. Abortion may be perceived as an evil but it is a necessary evil in some countries.

It's putting lipstick on a pig. Absolutely there should be more reasonable regulations for abortions but the UN has no business interfering in a law that protects the rights of the unborn either. Certainly a balance should be expected , one that allows for abortions in case of rape, incest. Birth Control education should be pushed and encouraged with easy access to BC for both men and women.
 

drSix

Silver
Oct 13, 2013
1,323
0
36
Post deleted by moderator : Don't bring religion into the regular forums

You've got to be kidding me.

Okay, then. So why does the DR ban abortion?


Because... Oh, can't say the word! Might as well delete the whole thread if we can't say the R word in an abortion thread.
 

mofongoloco

Silver
Feb 7, 2013
3,002
9
38
Any government which can control a woman's body to deny an abortion could be flipped to force an unwanted abortion. The government has no business telling a woman what to put into her vagina or what can come out of it.
 

Meemselle

Just A Few Words
Oct 27, 2014
2,844
389
83
Bob,
I think the reproductive health inference is directed mainly at the mental aspects of unwanted pregnancies, pregnancies caused by sexual assault, and pregnancies where the woman is carrying a child with severe physical and mental disabilities. Abortion is not accepted by all peoples and cultures, but you have to admit that the results of no abortion access are much worse in a country like the DR. The selling of young girls for prostitution, overpopulation, destitute children born into an endless cycle of poverty, etc. Many countries use pregnancy prevention education and abortion to control the population. India and China are two examples. Abortion may be perceived as an evil but it is a necessary evil in some countries.

How is it evil for a woman to have rights and control to her own body? Unless women have no right to rights. Riddle me that.
 
Apr 7, 2014
2,293
2
0
Criminalizing abortion in and of itself is a sign of an uncivilized government ?criminalizing abortion in a predominantly poor country should be considered a war crime.

I don't supposed those that desire to force women to birth children that they would otherwise choose not to would have any interest in foregoing their life?s income to support the children they forced to be brought into the world.
Im lost. Who is "forcing" them to have sexual intercourse? See...that there is already a crime. And if birth control is widely available and low cost where is this "force" you mention?
 
Apr 7, 2014
2,293
2
0
How is it evil for a woman to have rights and control to her own body? Unless women have no right to rights. Riddle me that.
She can control her body. Easily. Dont have sex. Thats the greatest control you can enact. Monks and nuns do it as a test of faith preferring the spiritual over the corporeal world.
 

ctrob

Silver
Nov 9, 2006
5,591
781
113
Any government which can control a woman's body to deny an abortion .

Except there's that little problem of the "other" body in that argument. Give the baby a vote in that decision and they will choose to live every time.
 

Chirimoya

Well-known member
Dec 9, 2002
17,850
982
113
So in the case of women or girls who have been forced into sex, as is quite often the case?
Or women who chose to get pregnant but the foetus is unviable, and/or the pregnancy threatens her life?

Those are the issues on the table in the DR and several other quasi-theocratic countries where victims of rape and incest, including young girls are forced into giving birth.
Where a teenager with cancer died during her pregnancy because the doctors could not give her chemotherapy. And women who are told that their baby has no chance of survival are forced to carry to term.
 

Ecoman1949

Born to Ride.
Oct 17, 2015
2,807
1,311
113
Any government which can control a woman's body to deny an abortion could be flipped to force an unwanted abortion. The government has no business telling a woman what to put into her vagina or what can come out of it.

Former Canadian Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau said it best, " The government has no place in the bedrooms of the nation".
 

Ecoman1949

Born to Ride.
Oct 17, 2015
2,807
1,311
113
Criminalizing abortion in and of itself is a sign of an uncivilized government ?criminalizing abortion in a predominantly poor country should be considered a war crime.

I don't supposed those that desire to force women to birth children that they would otherwise choose not to would have any interest in foregoing their life?s income to support the children they forced to be brought into the world.

If the shoe was on the other foot and men had the ability to give birth, abortion, birth control including voluntary sterilization would be readily available everywhere in the world.
 

Ecoman1949

Born to Ride.
Oct 17, 2015
2,807
1,311
113
She can control her body. Easily. Dont have sex. Thats the greatest control you can enact. Monks and nuns do it as a test of faith preferring the spiritual over the corporeal world.

Celibacy is nice in theory but not an effective means of birth control in real life, especially in poor countries where access to birth control is not available to the majority of the poor women or in male oriented (macho) cultures where women saying no to sex is not the norm. If your cloistered like monks and nuns then it's possible even though it goes against the sexual side of our human nature.
 
Last edited:
Apr 7, 2014
2,293
2
0
Celibacy is nice in theory but not an effective means of birth control in real life, especially in poor countries where access to birth control is not available to the majority of the poor women or in male oriented (macho) cultures where women saying no to sex is not the norm. If your cloistered like monks and nuns then it's possible even though it goes against the sexual side of our human nature.

Birth control is available EVERYWHERE and free for the traditional methods. Save that "These people are helpless so they need me to validate their existence" BS for Sally Struthers and those deceptively silly do-gooder liberals.
Machista aint got nothing to do with rape. Women here can always say no to sex. They dont because these tenuous relationships are only based on sex in the first place.


Maybe what they should do is teach people how to select better partners based on something greater than, "what is he going to give me?" If the women chose better partners they wouldnt have poorly constructed families always in dire need and circumstance.
 

Jaime809

Bronze
Aug 23, 2012
1,152
0
36
If the shoe was on the other foot and men had the ability to give birth, abortion, birth control including voluntary sterilization would be readily available everywhere in the world.

Hence Viagra et al being covered by insurance without so much as a peep, and birth control has seen court cases get to the SCotUS multiple times.