Well the countries are very different, both culturally, socially and geographically.
Whoever tells you The Bahamas is boring obviously didnt get out much. It depends where you go and what you do. There are 700 islands in the Bahamas from Nassau a small island with 200,000 people to Andros large island with just a couple thousand. The Bahamas has far more watersport opportunities due to many islands in protected waters. There is much more diving, fishing, boating, beaching, etc. Yes the beaches are the best in the world even better than Punta Cana.
The DR has the advantage of mountains (Bahamas highest point is 250 feet!) and much more terrain and many more towns/villages etc areas to visit. The Bahamas only has 300,000 residents while the DR has 8,000,000.
Your observations so far are pretty much on the money however the hotels in Bahamas I would say are of better quality than in the DR, even though as an average the Punta Cana area hotels might be better than Cable Beach strip in Nassau e.g. but there is no hotel like Atlantis in the DR. So at the end its probably about even when you figure shabby hotels on North Coast/Boca Chica area.
Bahamians would be a bit more educated and have a higher standard of living - I would agree with this - The Bahamas has had a huge advantage with small population, high tourism from the proximate U.S., and a history of living off the US via illegal actvities such as shipwrecking (1700's), gun and cotton running (war of independence, civil war), rum running during Prohibition in the 1920's, and then drug running in the 70s and 80's. Many Bahamians families became rich through these actvities.
This high standard of living through illegal activities has negative work-ethic results. Dominicans work much harder than Bahamians (I hope nobody reads this back home or I will be flogged!).
Generally, I would find Dominicans friendlier than Bahamians even though its not really fair to generalize like this. There are many exceptions on both sides in both directions. Bahamas is more racially divided while the DR is very mixed.
I couldn't say which I like better, I'd rather just focus on the good sides of each!
Ms.Z said:
I have read several posts from travellers to the Bahamas indicating that the Bahamas were extremely boring compared to the DR overall. I found that very surprising.
I hung out at various times in Freeport and Nassau for almost ten years and always had a great time with the local residents and other travellers, thoroughly enjoyed the food and loved the music (soca). The hotels overall are not the greatest (though the Ocean Club on Paradise Island is an exception) but the beaches in the Bahamas are absolutely gorgeous. Even though Bermuda is renowned for its pink sand, beaches on some of the Bahama islands have pink sand as well.
The Bahamians that I know are all very well educated and have a very high standard of living. I never experienced any problems with island infrastructure as I often read about that occur in the DR. And I always felt safe regardless of where I was in either Freeport or Nassau.
I would be interested to hear a Bahamians' point of view on the differences/similarities between the DR (which I plan to visit) and the Bahamas, positive and negative.
Ms. Z