i would go with reliable and pay the extra if you must..
in 2006, i shipped over 10 HUGE boxes of goods.. some used, some new... you name it electronics, household goods, clothes, kitchen supplies... EVERYTHING THAT WAS LEFT IN NYC OF MY HUSBAND, MY toddler SON & MY OWN PERSONAL GOODS... well... the co. shipped for us once before and we were given a reasonable rate and so we went with them! after the the supposedly delivery date came and went, and NONE of the co. phone #'s were being answered or WERE OUT OF SERVICE.. we tracked down the owner's family here in PP & were told that the owner of co. went 'BANKRUPT' and were given another contact person.. who then informed us that ALL of our goods were auctioned off to compensate for the losses of the new owners of the co.! We got police involved both here & in the states & nothing.. the owner disappeared & so did ALL our goods! just recently, my father shipped with a no-namer, LA FORTUNA cargo shipping, and they supposedly have 'sold' to another person.. a box shipped (xmas/bday gifts for my 4y.o. son) nov 20 has yet to been handed to us... i'm keeping my fingers crossed...
sorry to drag out my long stories.. i guess my point is that 'FENCING' is big business.. there is no way to track down these folks once they got your goods.. the best advice is to be sure there is an actual office location of shipping co. in both nyc & DR.. have someone or yourself visit the office.... (my receipts were fake addresses) see how long they've been in business too... SANTIAGO SHIPPING, AWILDA SHIPPING, MONTERO SHIPPING.. i believe are a start.. please don't go with cheap.. you'll pay in the long run!!!