Best Italian Restaurant in Cabarete/Sosúa

David B

Active member
Aug 31, 2017
270
176
43
I find generally Italian restaurants are good in the DR as many are run by Italians and a more authentic. I was told that Pasta Alfredo is a dish invented in the US. Maybe there is an americanized type Italian food that many of you are used to. With pizza I definitely like the thin Italian crisp ones better than the deep pan stuff from the US chains. Having said that I know Italian restaurants can be very good in the US.

Both La Tarappa and Las Palmas in Puerto Plata, if you're ever there, are run by Italians and have delicious, thin-crust pizza.
 
  • Like
Reactions: windeguy and aarhus

Big

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2019
4,792
3,977
113
The shortcuts and other methods needed to achieve such large and diverse quantities of food would sicken most humans if they had to witness the preparation and tour the walk-ins
lol, I never did understand the concept of "trough" eating. The "all you can eat" trough restaurant has killed millions more people than covid19
 

cavok

Silver
Jun 16, 2014
9,606
4,106
113
Cabarete
As someone commented here, that if you are from the US, Pizza and pasta with some ketchup thrown on top is (used to be) known as Italian....like for example, a chain restaurant called Olive Garden. Or in my neck of the woods, you could go to "Little Italy" and find that all the cooks are from central America, so much for Italian and then of course there is the "Italian steakhouse" - which I have never seen in Italy.
Not sure where you are talking about, but there were no central americans or mexicans in the south Philly area where I'm from when I grew up there. Best Italian food I've had anywhere. Pizza and pasta with ketchup on it is basically what you get almost everywhere here in the DR.
 
Sep 22, 2009
2,875
1,305
113
Not sure where you are talking about, but there were no central americans or mexicans in the south Philly area where I'm from when I grew up there. Best Italian food I've had anywhere. Pizza and pasta with ketchup on it is basically what you get almost everywhere here in the DR.
Grinders!
 

GusFring

Well-known member
Apr 15, 2020
532
272
63
Bliss is so average.
lol, I never did understand the concept of "trough" eating. The "all you can eat" trough restaurant has killed millions more people than covid19
So, speaking of intellect🙄
 

tempo

Active member
Aug 5, 2020
115
91
28
US
Not sure where you are talking about, but there were no central americans or mexicans in the south Philly area where I'm from when I grew up there. Best Italian food I've had anywhere. Pizza and pasta with ketchup on it is basically what you get almost everywhere here in the DR.
Sorry, I was NOT referring to South Philly in my post - but indeed someone else here confirmed my observation in some other geography.
I also am speaking as someone who lived in the EU for a long time and so my "Italian" is different from those that had Italian in the US. This is not to say that the Italian food in the US is not better than what it once was but, barring high class NY restaurant (I know nothing of CA and if I am in LA, I would go only to the Japanese Sashimi places), Italian food in the US is unrepresentative, first because historically it was food of the poor immigrants from the South, second because of US fascination with quantity (bigger portion is better and we can see the impact of that all around us) and finally, because it had to adjust to the local taste - the people of English/Scottish stock had only boiled stuff, which I enjoy during my NZ trips at English immigrants' residences, who maintain their own tradition there.
Italian food, whether from North or South is way superior - from a fish baked in oven, submerged inside nothing but sea salt in Genoa, to Orechhiette con cime de rapa in Bari. In the DR, I find better Italian food, a) because the restaurants I frequent are owned by the expat Italians, for example in Boca Chica/SD and b) there is a lot of genuine Italian ingredients available - some of which are not allowed into the US - for example someone mentioned "pancetta".
My favorite restaurant in Cabarete is my favorite, also because and this is fairly rare, that the Chef himself is Italian and not being from the South, has a different culinary footprint. In fact, the original owner of the Bologna restaurant was/is from Bologna and the food used to be excellent before it got sold off. By the way, I find the German and French restaurants around the North Coast to be very good too, again for similar reasons. I mean I found reibekuchen at a beachside place in Sosua - unthinkable!
 

Astucia

Papa de Negrita
Oct 19, 2013
678
364
63
Elefante Rosa. Located on Pedro Clisante in front of the former Britannia. The female owner is from Italy. Excellent food and very inexpensive. Big portions.
Agree - excellent and very inexpensive. And as you say- female owner is from Italy. From very simple and delicious ( pasta tossed in olive oil, garlic and hot pepper ) to very well done "red sauce" dishes that apparently some folks say can't be found here.

Forgot to also mention : lots of Italian patrons

Of course - they are located on that infamous block on PC. That will keep away many of the "never been there - never going there" folks. Their loss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aarhus

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
42,211
5,969
113
I find generally Italian restaurants are good in the DR as many are run by Italians and a more authentic. I was told that Pasta Alfredo is a dish invented in the US. Maybe there is an americanized type Italian food that many of you are used to. With pizza I definitely like the thin Italian crisp ones better than the deep pan stuff from the US chains. Having said that I know Italian restaurants can be very good in the US.
I suspect it is a regional difference. The Italians , and there were many, in my region were probably from southern Italy and Sicily. I had been told that was the red sauce area. In northern Italy, where I spent several days and had some very good meals, did not include one red sauce dish on their menus. Perhaps the northern Italians happened to land in the DR. Only one good red sauce report so far ( in Puerto Plata)...
 

ejl293

Member
May 29, 2012
89
54
18
What is the opinion of "Ceiba Cafe" located in Perla Marina? I like their pizza and have had a good eggplant parm there.
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
42,211
5,969
113
Sorry, I was NOT referring to South Philly in my post - but indeed someone else here confirmed my observation in some other geography.
I also am speaking as someone who lived in the EU for a long time and so my "Italian" is different from those that had Italian in the US. This is not to say that the Italian food in the US is not better than what it once was but, barring high class NY restaurant (I know nothing of CA and if I am in LA, I would go only to the Japanese Sashimi places), Italian food in the US is unrepresentative, first because historically it was food of the poor immigrants from the South, second because of US fascination with quantity (bigger portion is better and we can see the impact of that all around us) and finally, because it had to adjust to the local taste - the people of English/Scottish stock had only boiled stuff, which I enjoy during my NZ trips at English immigrants' residences, who maintain their own tradition there.
Italian food, whether from North or South is way superior - from a fish baked in oven, submerged inside nothing but sea salt in Genoa, to Orechhiette con cime de rapa in Bari. In the DR, I find better Italian food, a) because the restaurants I frequent are owned by the expat Italians, for example in Boca Chica/SD and b) there is a lot of genuine Italian ingredients available - some of which are not allowed into the US - for example someone mentioned "pancetta".
My favorite restaurant in Cabarete is my favorite, also because and this is fairly rare, that the Chef himself is Italian and not being from the South, has a different culinary footprint. In fact, the original owner of the Bologna restaurant was/is from Bologna and the food used to be excellent before it got sold off. By the way, I find the German and French restaurants around the North Coast to be very good too, again for similar reasons. I mean I found reibekuchen at a beachside place in Sosua - unthinkable!
Yep, northern Italian is not what I crave. It is indeed that southern Italian peasant food in quantity that was so good from back home.
 

tempo

Active member
Aug 5, 2020
115
91
28
US
It is obvious from reading the comments here, that we all like our childhood/comfort foods better.
The northern italian cuisine is different, abounds in white sauce as butter and cream (as in France as well) historically were local produce, as is rice - which is grown only in the north, hence risotto Milanese. The red sauce is a derivative of tomato, which is a product of the sun, i.e., the South - as is wheat (pizza and pasta hence) and of course olive oil, which is the "Italian" known in the US, because of the demography of the emigrants. By all means, sun ripe tomatoes, olive oil and a few sprigs of basil leaves, on top of a bowl of spaghetti, can be quick, scrumptious and memorable but it is just a fragment of ITALIAN cuisine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: interim888

Abuela

Bronze
May 13, 2006
1,954
289
83
What is the opinion of "Ceiba Cafe" located in Perla Marina? I like their pizza and have had a good eggplant parm there.
Their (Bruno's)homemade tagliatelle & ravioli are excellent as are all their other dishes including their pizza.
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
42,211
5,969
113
What is the opinion of "Ceiba Cafe" located in Perla Marina? I like their pizza and have had a good eggplant parm there.
I have had their pizza many times. Not like home but not bad for here. As good as I have found in the DR where there are many lousy examples of pizza. We had what was called an Italian sausage that was incredible as well as a tangier sauce and more of it. The crust was also thicker and a Sicilian pan pizza style, (NOT like Chicago), with a medium crust. For the Rome , Italy style cracker thin pizza we would go to Antonio's next to Janets.

I never tried other dishes at Ceiba.
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
42,211
5,969
113
It is obvious from reading the comments here, that we all like our childhood/comfort foods better.
The northern italian cuisine is different, abounds in white sauce as butter and cream (as in France as well) historically were local produce, as is rice - which is grown only in the north, hence risotto Milanese. The red sauce is a derivative of tomato, which is a product of the sun, i.e., the South - as is wheat (pizza and pasta hence) and of course olive oil, which is the "Italian" known in the US, because of the demography of the emigrants. By all means, sun ripe tomatoes, olive oil and a few sprigs of basil leaves, on top of a bowl of spaghetti, can be quick, scrumptious and memorable but it is just a fragment of ITALIAN cuisine.
No doubt, but the fragment I crave. The other stuff I will leave for you and others.

As for the pachyderm place people mention on PC in Sosua, no, it is not even close to the red sauce I am talking about. Nowhere near it.
 

tempo

Active member
Aug 5, 2020
115
91
28
US
No doubt, but the fragment I crave. The other stuff I will leave for you and others.

As for the pachyderm place people mention on PC in Sosua, no, it is not even close to the red sauce I am talking about. Nowhere near it.

I respect your choice! I love red sauces too but cannot do that all the time.
Btw, that was funny, your referring to the pachyderm! I went there many moons ago and yes, the woman is Italian. I remember having aglio, olio, peperoncino (garlic, olive oil, chili pepper) with spaghetti there and I cannot complain but to me it is nothing to write home about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: windeguy