Economic Imperialists should go home if Haiti is to solve its own problems internally

Yourmaninvegas

I am here to protect and serve
Feb 16, 2016
884
322
63
-

U.S. racism and imperialism fuel turbulence in Haiti​


Beginning on February 7, Haitians have been in the streets protesting against corruption, high prices, shortages, inflation, and power outages. Demonstrators are demanding that President Jovenel Moïse, in power since January 2017, resign. Moïse blames the disturbances on “armed groups and drug traffickers” and is calling for negotiation.

Facing police brutality, masses of Haitians have blocked roads, stoned officials, burned vehicles, and ransacked stores; nine are dead and over 100 wounded. Food and drinkable water are scarce. The United States withdrew non-emergency diplomatic representatives and issued travel warnings. The Trump administration indicated humanitarian aid may be on the way.

Haitians protested massively in October 2018 after the highly indebted government raised gasoline prices. It was complying with instructions from the International Monetary Fund in order to obtain low-interest loans. The protests forced a reversal of the price hike and continued.

Currently the Haitian people’s main complaint is corruption arising out of a 2006 oil deal with Venezuela. Haiti, led by President René Préval, was one of 17 countries joining Venezuela’s Petrocaribe project. The agreement called for Haiti to pay for 60 percent of the oil within 90 days and the remainder after 25 years at 1 percent interest. Haiti presently owes Venezuela $2 billion.

The government sold the oil to private entities and accumulated some $4 billion in funds. The idea was to use the money for sanitation, health care, education, infrastructure, and agricultural innovations. Needs mounted after the 2010 earthquake.

The funds were “misused, misappropriated, or embezzled by government officials and their cronies,” according to reports released by the Haitian Senate in 2017. Money flowed into the coffers of President Moïse’s business and into the hands of leaders of the political party formed by Michel Martelly, Moïse’s predecessor as president.

Haiti’s involvement with Petrocaribe ended in October 2017. U.S. anti-Venezuela sanctions had prevented Haiti from paying on its oil bill with Venezuela—or “gave them a golden excuse not to,” according to close Haiti observer Kim Ives. “Life in Haiti,” he writes, “which was already extremely difficult, now became untenable.” Ives castigates Haiti’s January 10 vote at the Organization of American States as “cynical betrayal by Moïse and his cronies.” That day Haiti supported a U.S. motion declaring President Maduro’s Venezuelan government to be “illegitimate.” Ives asserts that for deeply unhappy Haitians, “treachery against the Venezuelans after their exemplary solidarity…was the last straw.”

These troubles play out amid social disaster. For example, some 80 percent of Haitians live in poverty. Income inequality in Haiti, as reflected by the Gini index, rates as the world’s fourth most extreme case. Life expectancy ranks 154th in the world, and 40 percent of Haitians depend on agricultural income, while 80 percent of farms can’t feed families living on them.

This account now turns to background information. To begin: Michel Martelly became president courtesy of the U.S. government. Taking advantage of heightened distress in Haiti after the 2010 earthquake, the Obama administration retaliated against then-president René Préval. His offense was to have cooperated with the Venezuelan government of President Chávez in the matter of cheap oil.

Endorsed by military and paramilitary leaders, Martelly was able to compete in the 2010 presidential elections only after the Organization of American States and the U.S. government strong-armed Haiti’s Provisional Electoral Council. Secretary of State Clinton flew to Port-au-Prince to urge Préval “to get out of the way.”

In 2015 Martelly protégé Jovenel Moïse was elected president. As shown by legal observers from abroad, voting was marked by a 26 percent voter turnout, irregular procedures at the polls, and 50 percent fake ballots. The Electoral Council diagnosed fraud, appointed an interim president, and set repeat presidential elections for November 2016. Moïse won. The turnout was 21 percent. In Haiti, consequently, “there’s a huge apathy when it comes to elections.”

It wasn’t always that way. Progressive theologian Jean-Bertrand Aristide became president in 1990 with 67 percent of the vote. A U.S.-engineered military coup removed him eight months later. Paramilitaries led by CIA associate Emmanuel Constant subjected Aristide’s supporters to a reign of terror. He was re-elected in 2000 with a 92 percent plurality. Paramilitaries kidnapped him in 2004, again under U.S. auspices. The U.S. government transported him to the Central African Republic.

The United States isn’t alone in abusing Haiti’s national sovereignty. Soldiers of a United Nations “stabilization mission” arrived shortly after Aristide’s removal and stayed until 2017. Those troops introduced a cholera epidemic which added to Haiti’s woes.

What remains at this point is to explore the origins of Haiti’s chronic difficulties. The establishment-oriented U.S. Council on Foreign Relations recently–and reasonably–took note of factors like foreign intervention, debt, “instability” and natural disasters. But analyst Amy Wilentz goes to the essence of the problem, indirectly. Often the question regarding Haiti, she suggests, is: “How does a state fail?” She explains that “a state fails because of its history,” and not “because of some innate inferiority in its people.”

She thus politely refutes claims from those focused mainly on the fact that Black people established and have maintained the Haitian nation. Such views, racist in nature, point to the role of racism in thwarting Haiti’s development. Wilentz’s explanation as to a failed state needs modifying. In the case of Haiti, it ought to say: “a state may fail because of a history of racist assaults.”

When Haiti declared its independence in 1804, formerly enslaved people were free. France sought to recoup the money its citizens lost when slaves no longer were property. Threatening to blockade Haiti, France forced Haiti to provide compensation, and thus Haiti’s government between 1825 and 1947 paid France a total of $20 billion to settle the matter. Big question: What ethos other than white supremacy might induce high officials to assign monetary value to human beings who now, like white people, were ostensibly free?

Haiti became an independent republic in 1804, but it was not until 1862 that the United States extended diplomatic recognition and not until 1863 that U.S. economic sanctions were lifted. Racist attitudes were on display when the U.S. invaded Cuba in 1898. That was the heyday of Jim Crow, and a leading rationale was that of forestalling another black republic.” The rebel army included tens of thousands of Afro-Cubans.

The U.S. Army occupied Haiti for 19 years beginning in 1915. The advertised purpose was that of enforcing payments on debts owed to New York banks. But U.S. troops viciously employed torture and massacres as they squashed rebellions and uprisings.

Presidents Duvalier, father and son, ruled in Haiti between 1957 and 1986. They imposed murderous oppression, something that in Washington was purified through the rationale of anti-communism. In fact, U.S. actions in Haiti often have included elements of both racism and imperialism. The boundaries tend to blur.

Nevertheless, U.S. memories of Haiti helped to shape white America’s attitudes toward race. “American slaveholders trembled for their own security as they followed the tremendous revolutionary activity of the French West Indian slaves in the 1790s” (Herbert Aptheker, American Negro Slave Revolts). And in his biography of John Brown, ally of slaves, W.E.B. Du Bois states that Brown “was born just as the shudder of Hayti (sic) was running through all the Americas.”

Haiti became a special case, and probably still is.

 
  • Sad
  • Like
Reactions: Olly and DonDimi

NanSanPedro

Nickel with tin plating
Apr 12, 2019
2,152
1,756
113
I was in okap when the Venezuelan government provided a power plant. I think many went from electricity a couple of hours per week to over 12 per day. It was really dramatic.

As an ardent capitalist, I despise the socialism that the Venezuelan government put out, but they did help Haiti and something must be said good for that.
 
Jan 9, 2004
9,307
633
113
Exactly how I would write it up.............if I too were an avowed Marxist/Socialist/Communist organization.

It will likely take two more dictatorships, a revolution/civil war, and another 100 years before they even begin to make any progress............and until that time..............publications like peoplesworld.org will continue to do what all good Marxist/Socialist/Communist organizations do............blame someone else.

Kind of surprised they didn't toss the blame at the French and Dominican Republic in there too.


Respectfully,
Playacaribe2
 

Lobo Tropical

Silver
Aug 21, 2010
3,168
234
63
Exactly how I would write it up.............if I too were an avowed Marxist/Socialist/Communist organization.

It will likely take two more dictatorships, a revolution/civil war, and another 100 years before they even begin to make any progress............and until that time..............publications like peoplesworld.org will continue to do what all good Marxist/Socialist/Communist organizations do............blame someone else.

Kind of surprised they didn't toss the blame at the French and Dominican Republic in there too.


Respectfully,
Playacaribe2

Marxist/Socialist/Communist organizations do............blame someone else.

This modus operandi does not seem to be exclusive to the aforementioned.
You may view some current political happenings, including the last 5 years, using the same excuse blaming someone else-denying obvious reality.

All countries need the cooperation of private enterprise and government, to make countries work.
Just look at covid vaccine development and vaccinations.
Normally development takes 10-15 years.
Without government help, private business would not be involved in rapid development.
Neither would be investments in increased production facilities, which would not be needed later on.

Governments guaranteed biotech companies purchase orders and prices, along with receiving 100's of millions of government money for
Research and development of vaccines, socialism indeed for the common good!


Very catchy to use socialist slogans.
Some of the best operating economies are a mix of capitalist free enterprise with social components.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DonDimi

Yourmaninvegas

I am here to protect and serve
Feb 16, 2016
884
322
63
-
Capitalists only dislike economic systems that are not capitalist because it makes it hard to execute their economic imperialism through a market economy.
Yet, they find a way to make their money 💰 by getting in bed with the people who run the same systems they despise.
 

CristoRey

Double soy latte-sugar free syrup w/ 1% milk
Apr 1, 2014
6,662
2,896
113
Capitalists only dislike economic systems that are not capitalist because it makes it hard to execute their economic imperialism through a market economy.
Yet, they find a way to make their money 💰 by getting in bed with the people who run the same systems they despise.
You got a better plan?
I'm all ears.
 

bob saunders

Platinum
Jan 1, 2002
28,549
2,121
113
dr1.com
Marxist/Socialist/Communist organizations do............blame someone else.

This modus operandi does not seem to be exclusive to the aforementioned.
You may view some current political happenings, including the last 5 years, using the same excuse blaming someone else-denying obvious reality.

All countries need the cooperation of private enterprise and government, to make countries work.
Just look at covid vaccine development and vaccinations.
Normally development takes 10-15 years.
Without government help, private business would not be involved in rapid development.
Neither would be investments in increased production facilities, which would not be needed later on.

Governments guaranteed biotech companies purchase orders and prices, along with receiving 100's of millions of government money for
Research and development of vaccines, socialism indeed for the common good!


Very catchy to use socialist slogans.
Some of the best operating economies are a mix of capitalist free enterprise with social components.
Social components are not socialist components. Entirely different things.
 

Yourmaninvegas

I am here to protect and serve
Feb 16, 2016
884
322
63
-
You got a better plan?
I'm all ears.
I do not getting into a debate with you.
Because, I am not going to judge the economic systems of others.
Only the one I am most familiar with.
I am not going educate you.
Educate yourself if you have questions RayRay
But if you need an example of another successful economic system...read ‼️

China’s Wealthy Now Outnumber America’s​

 
  • Sad
  • Like
Reactions: Olly and DonDimi

Yourmaninvegas

I am here to protect and serve
Feb 16, 2016
884
322
63
-
Homogenous Scandanavian countries with small populations, financed by Oil Money. Not a realistic model for the rest of the world
And yet successful...
There is no economic model that is the best one for the entire world.
In my opinion.
I am not rolling with a superior attitude such as you have.
Unlike you, I do not know what is best for everyone in the world financially.
Nor do I know what is best economic system for each and every country in the world.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Olly

bob saunders

Platinum
Jan 1, 2002
28,549
2,121
113
dr1.com
I do not getting into a debate with you.
Because, I am not going to judge the economic systems of others.
Only the one I am most familiar with.
I am not going educate you.
Educate yourself if you have questions RayRay
But if you need an example of another successful economic system...read ‼️

China’s Wealthy Now Outnumber America’s​

Their poor still greatly outnumber the entire population of the USA.
 

melphis

Living my Dream
Apr 18, 2013
2,492
532
113
Why are the Clintons, Cooper Anderson and Sean Penn not here to fix Haiti's problems. They were collectively going to rebuild Haiti after the big earthquake.
I guess the cameras are not following them around blaming the DR and making them look somewhat good.

Build the wall. Let Haiti sort there own problems out.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: USA DOC and Caonabo

Yourmaninvegas

I am here to protect and serve
Feb 16, 2016
884
322
63
-
What I find most interesting is that those who think Haiti needs to solve their own problems...
Cannot even agree with me when I make the statement that the economic imperialists need to get out first.
If Haiti represents a bad investment.
Nations with capitalistic economies should be the first to recognize that and stop putting money into the country.
But they do...
Why ❓
But because they use as a money laundering spot.
To benefit everyone within their circle of favoritism
Doing little to nothing for the people of Haiti in the process.
 

NanSanPedro

Nickel with tin plating
Apr 12, 2019
2,152
1,756
113
What I find most interesting is that those who think Haiti needs to solve their own problems...
Cannot even agree with me when I make the statement that the economic imperialists need to get out first.
If Haiti represents a bad investment.
Nations with capitalistic economies should be the first to recognize that and stop putting money into the country.
But they do...
Why ❓
But because they use as a money laundering spot.
To benefit everyone within their circle of favoritism
Doing little to nothing for the people of Haiti in the process.
Be specific, what economic imperialists?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Olly

Yourmaninvegas

I am here to protect and serve
Feb 16, 2016
884
322
63
-
Be specific, what economic imperialists?
I cannot talk about it.
Because we cannot talk about any country other than Haiti in this thread.
Thread not about China, keep it Haiti related
It follows that I cannot name the specific economic imperialists as you request.
Get it cleared from AlterEgo and we can continue the discussion with the specificity you desire here.
The article I posted has examples of who might be classified as "economic imperialists".
It is an exercise for the read to figure out.
:ROFLMAO:
 

bob saunders

Platinum
Jan 1, 2002
28,549
2,121
113
dr1.com
I cannot talk about it.
Because we cannot talk about any country other than Haiti in this thread.

It follows that I cannot name the specific economic imperialists as you request.
Get it cleared from AlterEgo and we can continue the discussion with the specificity you desire here.
The article I posted has examples of who might be classified as "economic imperialists".
It is an exercise for the read to figure out.
:ROFLMAO:
That isn't entirely true, you can talk about those economic imperialists all you want as long as it is about their activity in Haiti.