Girl Missing from RIU Hotel in Punta Cana

El Hijo de Manolo

It's outrageous, egregious, preposterous!
Dec 10, 2021
5,619
3,741
113
Dominican Republic
I ended up putting one in a wheel chair while trying to stick him in the dirt, early 2000's. Never lost a minutes sleep over it either. I think I actually slept better afterwards.

When my good friend up in Cabarete drown in Nov 2021 his body washed up on the beach about 48 hours later. He was so badly decomposed due to the heat and saltwalter that initially they were unable to identify him.

If this young women was pulled into the ocean I do not believe this missing person's case will ever be solved.
I anticipate this thread eventually being closed without conclusion.
Well firstly that's a horrific end of life, may God continue to rest his soul.

Correct about water and salt effects as well. Regardless, this whole thing still smells worse than the Staten Island garbage dumps
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big and CristoRey

jose949

Active member
Oct 29, 2016
160
70
28
Idk, I find these Venmo transactions unsuspicious. It's a 20 year old girl from the US.
No issue, just providing the possibility that they may have gone there (a 2nd time) and returned to the resort, otherwise what is confirmed is they were last at an on-resort bar.

The article linked in #675 states "Riibe is under 24-hour surveillance while he remains on the island as of Friday, but is free to head back to the US." I wonder if that is accurate.
US MSNBC reported a little while ago that he is not free to leave and that his passport was taken away. They have reached out to PN and are yet to hear back.
 

jose949

Active member
Oct 29, 2016
160
70
28
Based on his experience in judicial matters, the criminal expert considered that the Public Prosecutor’s Office should already be taking action, either to free him or to request that the judge ensure that he remains in the country until his involvement, or lack of involvement, in this case, is determined. This case concerns Dominican society and could affect tourism to the Dominican Republic https://dominicantoday.com/dr/touri...he-inconsistencies-in-joshua-riibes-versions/
 

El Hijo de Manolo

It's outrageous, egregious, preposterous!
Dec 10, 2021
5,619
3,741
113
Dominican Republic
I ended up putting one in a wheel chair while trying to stick him in the dirt, early 2000's. Never lost a minutes sleep over it either. I think I actually slept better afterwards.

When my good friend up in Cabarete drown in Nov 2021 his body washed up on the beach about 48 hours later. He was so badly decomposed due to the heat and saltwalter that initially they were unable to identify him.

If this young women was pulled into the ocean I do not believe this missing person's case will ever be solved.
I anticipate this thread eventually being closed without conclusion.
Adding results of this search for clarity:

Understanding the Impact on Forensic Evidence:

After 48 hours in the ocean, most trace forensic evidence, such as DNA from the perpetrator or gunpowder residue, is likely to be destroyed due to water exposure and marine activity. However, key evidence like physical wounds from gunshots, knife attacks, or brute force (e.g., fractures) may still be visible, though their clarity could be reduced. This means forensic experts can often determine the cause of death, such as identifying bullet wounds or stab marks, and use the victim’s DNA for identification, even in challenging conditions.

What Can Be Salvaged?
- Physical wounds, like gunshot or stab injuries, may still be discernible, helping identify the murder method.
- Fractures from brute force can remain detectable in bones.
- The victim’s DNA, crucial for identification, is likely still recoverable from the body.
- Unexpectedly, items like bullets or the murder weapon, if still with the body, might also be found, though trace evidence like perpetrator DNA on these items could be lost.

This balance shows that while much trace evidence is lost, critical details for investigation can often be salvaged, depending on ocean conditions and the body’s state.
 

CristoRey

Welcome To Wonderland
Apr 1, 2014
13,873
10,024
113
Based on his experience in judicial matters, the criminal expert considered that the Public Prosecutor’s Office should already be taking action, either to free him or to request that the judge ensure that he remains in the country until his involvement, or lack of involvement, in this case, is determined. This case concerns Dominican society and could affect tourism to the Dominican Republic https://dominicantoday.com/dr/touri...he-inconsistencies-in-joshua-riibes-versions/
Interesting link/ read.
I agree.
Charge him or send him home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jose949

JD Jones

Moderator:North Coast,Santo Domingo,SW Coast,Covid
Jan 7, 2016
15,034
11,128
113
Adding results of this search for clarity:

Understanding the Impact on Forensic Evidence:

After 48 hours in the ocean, most trace forensic evidence, such as DNA from the perpetrator or gunpowder residue, is likely to be destroyed due to water exposure and marine activity. However, key evidence like physical wounds from gunshots, knife attacks, or brute force (e.g., fractures) may still be visible, though their clarity could be reduced. This means forensic experts can often determine the cause of death, such as identifying bullet wounds or stab marks, and use the victim’s DNA for identification, even in challenging conditions.

What Can Be Salvaged?
- Physical wounds, like gunshot or stab injuries, may still be discernible, helping identify the murder method.
- Fractures from brute force can remain detectable in bones.
- The victim’s DNA, crucial for identification, is likely still recoverable from the body.
- Unexpectedly, items like bullets or the murder weapon, if still with the body, might also be found, though trace evidence like perpetrator DNA on these items could be lost.

This balance shows that while much trace evidence is lost, critical details for investigation can often be salvaged, depending on ocean conditions and the body’s state.
It's been nine days. I'll leave what's left after 9 days to your imagination.
 

cavok

Silver
Jun 16, 2014
11,256
5,168
113
Cabarete
Since Riibes is a permanent US resident, I think he could still be prosecuted in the US if he is sent back and evidence is found in the future.
 

CristoRey

Welcome To Wonderland
Apr 1, 2014
13,873
10,024
113
Since Riibes is a permanent US resident, I think he could still be prosecuted in the US if he is sent back and evidence is found in the future.
No.
It requires going thru the extradition process which I'm sure he would fight. At that point the evidence would need to be overwhelming and a warrant issued for his arrest by Dominican authorities.
 

jose949

Active member
Oct 29, 2016
160
70
28
FWIW
Stephen Leatherman, a professor of Earth and Environment at Florida International University, also thought eight days was too long for her body to be at sea.

'If she drowned, her body should have already surfaced in the warm Caribbean waters,' he said.

'I have served as an expert witness for 30 years, so I have been involved in many cases where someone drowned in a rip current, but the body was always recovered.

'I think that there must be another explanation for her disappearance.'

Leatherman, known as Dr Beach for his encyclopedic knowledge of coastlines, also rubbished a theory that her body was stuck on a reef. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14500335/Sudiksha-Konanki.html
 

jd426

Gold
Dec 12, 2009
10,103
3,425
113
Blue Collar Town in New Jersey
I ended up putting one in a wheel chair while trying to stick him in the dirt, early 2000's. Never lost a minutes sleep over it either. I think I actually slept better afterwards.

When my good friend up in Cabarete drown in Nov 2021 his body washed up on the beach about 48 hours later. He was so badly decomposed due to the heat and saltwalter that initially they were unable to identify him.

If this young women was pulled into the ocean I do not believe this missing person's case will ever be solved.
I anticipate this thread eventually being closed without conclusion.
Unless they BREAK him ( IF he did it of course)
There is Precedent here in the states that you CAN convict without a Body ..
Ergo my earlier post and question about Extraditing him back to the states , and if this would be double Jeopardy..
In Fact We had one less than 10 Miles from my house in NJ, woman body was thrown off the Belmar Bridge, never found
They convicted the Killers , with evidence and I think a solid confession with details .

Some said the confession was not real, and the woman made a Suicide Pact.. ( there is a Movie about such a case)
but I doubt that was it .. it was clear cut THEFT and Murder .
No body was ever found .
 

El Hijo de Manolo

It's outrageous, egregious, preposterous!
Dec 10, 2021
5,619
3,741
113
Dominican Republic
Interesting link/ read.
I agree.
Charge him or send him home.
The public ministry has the entire legal right to place Riibe under preventative custody (as member SKY had previously mentioned re Dominican law), if and only needing an if, foul play is even suspected with minimal circumstantial evidence. This can be any period of time determined by a judge up to 18 months with a case review every three months.

That said, it is my hope, if still no body or trace of the girl is found, that they completely excercise their right to preventative custody. Closing the case right now, especially since the body has not been found in 9 days, and taking into consideration the multiple varying accounts from Riibe, would be a legal shame and a true injustice for the family of the girl.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big

El Hijo de Manolo

It's outrageous, egregious, preposterous!
Dec 10, 2021
5,619
3,741
113
Dominican Republic
No.
It requires going thru the extradition process which I'm sure he would fight. At that point the evidence would need to be overwhelming and a warrant issued for his arrest by Dominican authorities.
Not 100% accurate. The US maintains certain jurisdiction in this case, but yes the extradition agreement between DR and US could come into play.

Sources: 18 USC, Sections 1119 and 1203
 

cavok

Silver
Jun 16, 2014
11,256
5,168
113
Cabarete
No.
It requires going thru the extradition process which I'm sure he would fight. At that point the evidence would need to be overwhelming and a warrant issued for his arrest by Dominican authorities.
The DR could request that he be extradited but there's still nothing to prevent the US from prosecuting him since both he and the girl are US permanent US residents.
 

Big

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2019
6,074
5,254
113
I have zero experience in legal criminal matters. However as a quasi gentleman with a shred of decency and dose of humanity if I (or anyone I know for that matter) were with a woman, even if it was a one night stand, I would see to it that she was alive after I enjoyed her company. At the very least I would have alerted an authority figure perhaps a front desk clerk or a security guard and report the incident. I certainly would not go to my room and just "sleep it off". As a man I would have difficulty living with myself
 

El Hijo de Manolo

It's outrageous, egregious, preposterous!
Dec 10, 2021
5,619
3,741
113
Dominican Republic
I have zero experience in legal criminal matters. However as a quasi gentleman with a shred of decency and dose of humanity if I (or anyone I know for that matter) were with a woman, even if it was a one night stand, I would see to it that she was alive after I enjoyed her company. At the very least I would have alerted an authority figure perhaps a front desk clerk or a security guard and report the incident. I certainly would not go to my room and just "sleep it off". As a man I would have difficulty living with myself
And therein lies the crux of the matter in our cornfield-born wrestler's suspiciousness and involvement. Only as the esteemed Caymus-sipping fine gentleman from Santo Domingo could tell it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jd426 and Big

cavok

Silver
Jun 16, 2014
11,256
5,168
113
Cabarete
The problem there is, not everybody has a conscience that would bother them. The world is full of sociopaths,
 

jd426

Gold
Dec 12, 2009
10,103
3,425
113
Blue Collar Town in New Jersey
No.
It requires going thru the extradition process which I'm sure he would fight. At that point the evidence would need to be overwhelming and a warrant issued for his arrest by Dominican authorities.
Incorrect . the US has an agreement with the DR ..
Its already been discussed and researched .. If they ask for him, the DR will gladly comply. Its not a problem to ship him back