554 number is in Higuey so it should be in Higuey. El Naranjo area is also in front of basilica, so that should verify. But I haven't heard of Naranjo hotel. There are couple of hotels around basilica, and there is one that seems to be "nicer" than the rest of the bunch, and also way more expensive. It is in front of the Esso gas station, near Rochel. It well might be the one mentioned by NALs.