I agree Johne, it's really a shame. I think what we need here is some raw, hard data. Let's investigate, shall we?
8,398 criminal incidents in "Santo Domingo", 1,795 in Distrito Nacional.
La provincia de Santo Domingo registró el mayor número de homicidios en República Dominicana, con 294 víctimas en 2021.
es.statista.com
They only allow one time viewing so I can't get the numbers but homicides are much higher in Santo Domingo than Distrito Nacional
5-year period, double homicides in Santo Domingo province than Distrito Nacional
Este documento presenta un análisis en materia de seguridad ciudadana con datos a junio 2021, los cuales son producidos por las instancias nacionales responsables de la gestión de información sobre seguridad ciudadana en República Dominicana: Observatorio de Seguridad Ciudadana (OSC-RD)...
infosegura.org
Statistical breakdown
Gestión de información sobre Seguridad Ciudadana basada en evidencia
infosegura.org
Statistical breakdown
These numbers and reports are not the best ones I've found. I spent a few weeks painstakingly reserarching crime stats on the island and within Santo Domingo. I'll do some digging and find the reports I've stumbled upon in the past. For now the above data should suffice.
In the "Walking" thread currently on the front page, posted by Rey I have deliniated an area smaller than "Distrito Nacional" that is relatively safe for tourists, residents and locals. This area is from the Luperon (better the Nuñez de Caceres) to the Zona Colonial, South of JFK from the Luperon (or Nuñez de Caceres) to the Gomez, South of Avenida Mexico from Gomez to the river. North of Independencia from Luperon (or Nuñez de Caceres) to Gomez. In the west, Luperón becomes Próceres and that connects to the Jardin Botanico. Everything within that (to the east) is reasonably ok. Outside is Los Rios, where I would not recommend a foreigner go. It isn't necessarily "dangerous" but it's just not your sector. And sticking out can cause problems.
Statistically, by the numbers, DN is safer than Este, period. If you take out Capotillo, Los Guandules, Villa Consuelo, Villa Juana, Libertad, all of that which is north of JFK, if you take out Barrio Chino, Parque Enriquillo/Villa Fransisco, all that which is north of Avenida Mexico and you eliminate everything south of Independencia from Luperon to the Churchill, or the Gomez you are cutting out the VAST MAJORITY of the dangerous areas within Distrito Nacional. It becomes quite a "safer" area in fact, especially in contrast to the areas mentioned in this paragraph and the remainder of Santo Domingo. This is where the majority of middle and upper class people spend their time when within Santo Domingo.
I've been in these areas extensively, I've walked around, driven around, been ubered around. I know people that live there. I've been in people's houses and apartments, I've walked girls home or dropped them off, I've done business in these areas extensively, I have relationships with service providers. I have not spent a single day with an expat here in this country. All of the information I've received anecdotally has been from dominicans who have lived here their entire life, or 1-2 who lived in the US for a while and then moved back. I am telling you what I know. I am telling you what they've told me. Unless Rey is a bold-faced liar the police have told them what THEY know. The statistics are telling you about the reported and recorded events that have occurred in the past.
It's your job to use this information wisely.