That's an interesting song. I can tell you about my experience. First I married a beautiful girl. After ten years she dumped me for another guy. However those ten years were great. Next I married a girl who was attractive, but not beauty pageant material. After two years she gained weight and was kind of ugly. And the more ugly she got, the meaner she got. We were together for 18 years. The last ten were hell. I only stayed for the kids.
So I'd say, all things considered, the beauty was a better deal. Whatever else happens, at least you are getting some happiness.
I'm now single 8 years and I will be celebrating my 60th birthday this month.
I've arranged for a girl I met on Dominican Cupid to meet me at the airport. Pure Playboy centerfold material. Yes, everything may go wrong, however I have a feeling that I will have a few good memories and that's better than nothing.