Merengue Vs. Bachata

Marianopolita

Former Spanish forum Mod 2010-2021
Dec 26, 2003
4,821
766
113
Talldrink,

Nice post but take a look, Frank Reyes is part of my "fab five" as you call it. When I first read this I thought how could I make such a mistake. But he's there on the list.

Echa un vistazo.


Talldrink said:
Lesly, I would replace Alex Bueno and add Frank Reyes to the Fab Five in Bachateros (my personal taste) I love Alex, but Frank has it over him when it comes to bachata. Alex is good at everything else, still one of my favs nonetheless.

Mr. Defender, I used to HATE Aventura, I did not get on to them until their second album. I find that they have great songwriters and nice music arrangments. But as with many other great bachateros, I admit, they cannot sing too well (like I said, many other bachateros really dont have great voices either) and some little sayings can get corny. But the lyrics, emotions, and music portrayed by Bachata make it a nice package that makes you forget all else wrong with the songs or artist.

We do have to give groups like Aventura (and others) some credit because they have done what the Greats (like Lesly would call them) were not able to do, and is to bring Bachata to a younger audience and reach a different demographic area.

I also agree with you that they wont be around for long, but the fact that they did well at one point in time and many new and younger ones discovered bachata because of them, should not be forgotten.
 

Jersey Devil

Bronze
Jul 5, 2002
686
0
16
Merengue vs. Bachata

As my Cross Country coach in High School said about dual meets,
bachata is like meat and potatoes. A staple. Music that one
can listen to and dance to at any time. However I enjoy
dancing to merengue just as much as I do bachata, if not
more.

JD
 

Tomvangeffen

New member
May 9, 2002
28
0
0
straying off-topic again....

bueno,

so much has been said now, and so many artists named that i am tempted to stray off a little again and ask you guys:

What do you think about " La India"

I know: not bachata , but she did some merengue and some really strong Salsa.I really like her very typical voice...

Tom
 

Marianopolita

Former Spanish forum Mod 2010-2021
Dec 26, 2003
4,821
766
113
Just to satisfy your curiosity because I think we should stick to the thread topic "merengue and bachata", salsa should have it's own thread if you want to discuss this genre buy anyway:

My opinion about La India is she had her moments of fame in the 90's, never was big on my list of salsa artists but she has some nice songs. For example, Vivir lo nuestro (with Mark A) is a classic, "Ese Hombre" and "Nunca voy a olvidarte". These are some salsas that gave her recoginition. Personally, I stopped following her music after the album which has these three songs- It's titled Dicen que soy..The other album that I liked from her Sobre el fuego never made it big and that's where I think she started to lose ground. In general, she has been quiet but her album release last year I think is an attempt to tell her fans that she's back. I personally think her latest album "Songbird" is good but once again it's not popular (as far as I know). I never hear songs played from the album when I go dancing and that's the way I judge if a salsa and merengue and bachata for that matter are popular among its fans. In genreal she's good but she's not Celia Cruz (q.p.d) which promoters tried to label her as "la princesa" de la salsa with respect to la Dona Celia.

You have to keep in mind salsa is a very interesting genre. It fascinates me because of how it began with "el son cubano" and then in NY in the 50's with some acoustic changes etc. it became known as "salsa". When it comes to salsa I like to be regionalistic. I like the best of best from the Cuban artists like Issac Delgado, Adalberto Alvarez and Albita. You can't beat these artists. I love authentic Puerto Rican salsa. It goes right to your soul. The only group to me that stands out in this regard is El Gran Combo. Talking about longevity! They are still great. Songs like "El timbalero" and "No hay cama pa' tanta gente". No salsa group today can match songs like except maybe "La Sonora Carruseles" and "Fruko". Colombia, I give my hats to them. Some tremendous music originates from that beautiful country and their salsa to me is one of the finest. Groups like Grupo Niche (the older music), Orquesta Guayacan, La Sonora Carruseles, La Misma Gente, Joe Arroyo, the Latin Brothers and Fruko y sus Tesos are all excellent represenatives of "la salsa colombiana". Tierra querida.

In general salsa to me is terrific music, one of best genres of tropical music and most difused internationally. That perscusion, drums and "timbales" makes it hard to resist. Que viva la salsa.

There are okay Dominican salsa artists as well but in general when I think about salsa I don't think of the DR but Raulin Rosendo is okay. Santiago Cerron is traditional in style but nice. Cuco Valoy- depends on your taste. He's outdated.

That's all for now.

Lesley D



Tomvangeffen said:
bueno,

so much has been said now, and so many artists named that i am tempted to stray off a little again and ask you guys:

What do you think about " La India"

I know: not bachata , but she did some merengue and some really strong Salsa.I really like her very typical voice...

Tom
 

Talldrink

El Mujeron
Jan 7, 2004
2,209
42
0
First and Foremost, after bachata salsa is my next favorite - India and Marc are on the top of my list. We should start another thread about it...

I will like to add that good music - because it is a personal choice and should not be driven by what others consider good enough to give top play - should not be judged by the amount of marketing behind it or how much it is played in the clubs. If that were the case, then JLo would be the 'Queen' of all genres after all - and we all know better than that!