Husband and I stayed in Costambar - a gated community with many ex-pats wintering there in homes they own just west of Puerto Plata - this Feb. Rented a 2 bedroom condo for only $500 a week! Stones throw from a nice, QUIET beach (make sure to give the guy you rent chairs from on the beach a nice tip....very nice young man!!). If you are looking for excitement, this is not really the place. If you are looking for inexpensive yet nice and quiet with great food, this is GREAT! We had fantastic meals everywhere we ate (tiny little restaurants all over!) - Buddies, Solo Mio, also the restaurant right on that beach, to name a few. And yes, Blackbeards IS basically a brothel, but seemed nice and clean, etc in the bar/restaurant area (we just HAD to go in for a "look"!). Here is the website for the place we rented:
www.tedriskin.com/DR only problem was it was somewhat noisy and the water was not always hot for showers, but it was a very nice condo close to the beach.