Hi Grant & Sharon, I too have stayed at the Don Juan many times(not quite as many as Jim though, but over 15 times) I really like the hotel and the location is second to none, with a captains club room you are assured of very little noise at night, the food is good in my opinion but to each thier own. I was there 2 weeks ago and was in a captain club room and had a wonderful stay, I would highly recommend it over the Boca Chica Beach Resort, as I have stayed there many times also(before and after they added the second pool.) I find everyone has thier own idea of what is good and what is not, so you'll have to check it out for yourself. Jim Hinsh is very well travelled in the area and if he has nothing bad to say about it, nor do I, than take it from there. Have a great trip and tell us about your stay when you return. Have fun .....catch ya later....Doug