You have read between the lines when taking the opinion of some motoring journalists, who write for these consumer magazines / websites. *They are so very subjective.
One American writer writing an article for the new Jaguar XF completely slated it because it didn't have enough cup holders! *Perhaps that compared to the UK where you have to take out a small loan to fill the tank. *Diesel is currently $6 a gallon in the UK. *So to the American, a premium vehicle that does nearly 50mpg in utter silence and refinement isn't important. *But cup holders are.
Read reviews on the Land Cruiser and Land Cruiser Prado from Australia and you will get a completely different opinion.
NB. *Most Land cruisers here have the straight six diesel engine which is virtually indestructible.
Reviews are very subjective to be sure.
But the Jaguar is absolute rubbish for a luxury vehicle.
Forget the cup holders for a moment and look what happens after you buy one. Jaguars have one of the worst records of value depreciation in the automobile luxury space.
People vote with their dollars/euros/yen based on things way beyond cup holders. The vehicle is expensive junk and I am not sure the current brand owner Tata Motors can successfully revive it.
Respectfully,
Playacaribe2