Dominican Baseball Experts: Your Opinion.

NY1

New member
Feb 26, 2002
512
2
0
miguel said:
True, about the players that we do not know, but lets not forget about the american players that are also playing overseas or in AAA.

PLEASE, miguel you sound like someone who knows nothing about baseball. If you're an American player playing overseas, YOU SUCK!! There is no one in AAA that would be worthy of being on this team, PERIOD. If they were, they wouldn't be in AAA.

About the Licey comment: All I wanted to state was that El Licey won so many times because Lasorda used to take some of his Dodgers players (regulars and from AAA), after the season was over, to play for El Licey in the DR.

There is a big difference between the state of Dominican baseball in the 1970's and the year 2000. Perhaps that may be the case, more than Lasorda's management skills?

I hope that you are not trying to say that the US is NOT the team to beat?.

Nope, but I will let other journalists tell you...

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/si_online/news/2003/04/22/bb/

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=schoenfield/050511



I'll post more articles from those who know if you want, just let me know.
 

trina

Silver
Jan 3, 2002
2,550
11
0
NY1 said:
You seem to forget, that not only does DR have some good players, they have arguably the top 6 players in the game.


As for the 25 man roster someone asked about:

1. 2b Alfonso Soriano
2. 3B Alex Rodriguez
3. DH David Ortiz
4. LF Manny Ramirez
5. SS Miguel Tejada
6. RF Vladimir Guerrero
7. 1b Albert Pujols
8. CF Jose Guillen
9. C Miguel Olivo

Bench:

Juan Encarnacion
Luis Castillo
Adrian Beltre
Aramis Ramirez
Moises Alou

P Pedro Martinez
Bartolo Colon
Odalis Perez
Jorge Sosa
Runelvys Hernandez

Francisco Cordero
Jose Mesa
Yhency Brazoban
Felix Rodriguez
Armando Benitez (if healthy)
Damaso Marte



That's the 25 best that I find. Of course they'd also need a backup catcher like Alberto Castillo, but, oh well. Willy Mo Pena and Rafael Furcal would also look good on that team as well, but no room.


Excellent choices. I'd like to see Pujols on third again - he was an even better 3B than first. Move A-Rod over to SS, where he excels. Tejada to 2B - Soriano an alternate. That would free up first for my all-time fave Julio Franco. You never know how many seasons he has left, so give him the honor...besides, he's still incredible for his age...he'd be a great leader and motivator for the team to boot.
 

NY1

New member
Feb 26, 2002
512
2
0
Actually reading the rules, I did see that the teams would comprise of actually 27 players. That list of 25 are the ones most deserving IMO. However, as you stated with Franco, I am sure they will have some old-timers on the team, rather than some of the younger players.

Other than Franco, of course Sammy Sosa would probably be invited. I would imagine so would Jose Lima, perhaps even Offerman. These last 2 are staples of the DR Winter league. I just hope they don't dig too deep and resurrect someone like Henry Rodriguez, who did play in DR this past winter.
 

miguel

I didn't last long...
Jul 2, 2003
5,257
2
0
114
Wrong!

NY1 said:
PLEASE, miguel you sound like someone who knows nothing about baseball. If you're an American player playing overseas, YOU SUCK!! There is no one in AAA that would be worthy of being on this team, PERIOD. If they were, they wouldn't be in AAA.



There is a big difference between the state of Dominican baseball in the 1970's and the year 2000. Perhaps that may be the case, more than Lasorda's management skills?
I just hope that those "baseball knows-it-all" would just read the whole thread before they quote a post.

I mentioned american players overseas because I was replying to a poster who was saying that there are, also, many good dominicans playing in other countries. Get it?. Cool, now let's move on to the next misquotation:

If you are a baseball fan and can go as far as the '70's, you will find out that El Licey won so many times because Lasorda would bring his good american players, from the big leagues and AAA, to play for them. Before and after he did that, Licey had won just a few times.

I started playing baseball, I think, while in diapers. I played baseball from little league all the way to college. I up to this day, 43 soon, I still play baseball every now and then. I was one of those baseball fan that would keep a book just for teams and players stats(going back 30 some years), all players. I have a book collection about baseball that takes 75% of one of my bookcases. I thought that I had forgotten more about baseball than many would learn in a lifetime. BUT you are more than right, I know nothing about baseball. I really do not know many things but I was sure that I knew my baseball and boxing. Oh well, 1 out of 2 is not that bad!.

The thing with some of you guys is that some of you are not baseball fans. Some of you are Dominican players fans.

Let me give you an example of a fan:

Martinez is pitching against my beloved Yankees. Althought I like Martinez and I know that he is a great pitcher, I still DO NOT want him to beat the Yankees. To me it has nothing to do with him being dominican. It has to do with me wanting my team to win. Ok, I rather see him get a no-decision, but in reality I would be happier if the Yankees win than if he beats them.

Another example?. OK:

Martinez is pitching against Colon. Since I like both, I would cheer for the one that is doing better.

Yes, I love it when dominican players are doing well (as long as they are not doing well against the Yankees). I feel proud of them. But to me is NOT a dominican thing, it's a baseball thing and seeing things for what they are.

Btw, and I will say it again: lets not make a big deal about this "thing". Many will not be allowed to play. MANY. Some will opt not to play. Gary Sheffield already said that he would not play. He said that he would not risk getting injured since he would not be getting paid.
 
Last edited:

NY1

New member
Feb 26, 2002
512
2
0
miguel said:
I mentioned american players overseas because I was replying to a poster who was saying that there are, also, many good dominicans playing in other countries. Get it?.

I did see the reference you were responding to. Here's the difference. Each MLB team only gets a certain number of visas for your entire organization. So once you've used up your allotment, you can't have anymore foreigners. This is why you rarely see a foreigner as the 25th player on a team. Thus players who might still be able to play in MLB, ie Tony Fernandez, Julio Franco, Offerman, Henry Rodriguez to name a few, go overseas. Such is not the case for the American players. if you go overseas, its because, well you're not that good at the MLB level.

If you are a baseball fan and can go as far as the '70's, you will find out that El Licey won so many times because Lasorda would bring his good american players, from the big leagues and AAA, to play for them. Before and after he did that, Licey had won just a few times.

Again, you simply cannot compare the state of Dominican baseball in the 70's until today. That's like comparing the US dominance in basketball in the 70's and 80's and using that to justify why they will dominate in the next basketball world cup.
Now as for Licey's dominance that you speak about in the 70's, let us delve into their history of winning the Caribbean Series. They won it in 1971, 1973 and 1977, ONLY 1973 was won by Lasorda. 1971 Manny Mota was the manager and Bob Rodgers was the manager in 1977.
BTW, in case you're wondering what they did after Lasorda and his Dodger players left, they also won it in 1980, 1985, 1991, 1994, 1999 and 2003. Not bad, eh?

The thing with some of you guys is that some of you are not baseball fans. Some of you are Dominican players fans.

Sorry, you must have me confused with someone else. If you want to talk about baseball in general, I'd love to do it. I'm a Mets fan. Sucks for me, I know, but if you want to delve into the history of baseball, I'd love to. However the thread won't go far, since it is a DR related website, guess what, the threads should be DR related.
I love good baseball, but cringe when Pujols comes up to the plate against my team. I want him to do well as a Dominican, against other teams, but sure as heck root for him to go 0-4 everytime he plays my Mets.
Pedro started his career 9-0 against the Mets, I hated his guts, because of what he did to my team each time he went to the mound. Then he moved to the AL, and I was able to appreciate his dominance as a baseball fan, knowing my team would only have to face him every few years. Then it would be back to hating Pedro on those outings. So you may want to point that finger elsewhere.

Btw, and I will say it again: lets not make a big deal about this "thing". Many will not be allowed to play. MANY. Some will opt not to play. Gary Sheffield already said that he would not play. He said that he would not risk getting injured since he would not be getting paid.

We can agree about that. The point however is that Selig has received approval from virtually all the owners. Make no mistake, this is a money making venture for MLB, plain and simple and the owners will reap the benefits. Are there risks, sure, however, if the NBA and NHL can take that risk to promote their sports in the Olympics, why can't MLB? Its all about the bottom line.
You know full well, that its diferent for the latin players. No matter how much money Vlad, Tejada and Ortiz make, they still want to play for their country, which is why they play winter ball. There is pressure on these players also to play, not so for the US players, as Sheffield has so eloquently put it.
 
Last edited:

DRPAWA

New member
Sep 3, 2004
140
0
0
No you didn't Miguel....

Sorry about the late reply but I only get a few minutes a day at work to do this - much as I enjoy it.

When you said yesterday that, "Comparing 'gringos" talents to any other talents is like comparing oranges to apples!. Not trying to take anything away from the good spanish players but in my opinion (NOTE: MY OPINION) for every good spanish player, there are 5 or more better "gringo" players" you are WRONG! First of all, for a man of with your stated baseball history to even imply this is shocking. Secondly, it's even more shocking that noone called you out on this point.

The simplest way to state my case is just to say that if the above were true, there would be no Domincan player playing in the MLB. Why should there be? For charity?
It is clearly evident that Dominicans are among the best players in the world. Just look at the recent All-Star game. There were, I believe 12 players born in DR (you can add A-Rod as being Dominican which would make it 13). And, remember that Pedro did not participate (14!).

I will contend that for a Dominican player to make it to the majors he not only has to be as good as the gringo players but rather he has to be better than most of the other gringo players contending for the position.

I do hope you agree with me Miguel.
 

trina

Silver
Jan 3, 2002
2,550
11
0
DRPAWA said:
When you said yesterday that, "Comparing 'gringos" talents to any other talents is like comparing oranges to apples!. Not trying to take anything away from the good spanish players but in my opinion (NOTE: MY OPINION) for every good spanish player, there are 5 or more better "gringo" players" you are WRONG! First of all, for a man of with your stated baseball history to even imply this is shocking. Secondly, it's even more shocking that noone called you out on this point.


Did you ever think that maybe some of us just don't bother reading it anymore? ;) :bandit:
 

rellosk

Silver
Mar 18, 2002
4,170
59
48
trina said:
Did you ever think that maybe some of us just don't bother reading it anymore? ;) :bandit:
Ditto. These types of discussions are best held over a cold Presidente, they become tiresome on a message board.
 

NY1

New member
Feb 26, 2002
512
2
0
rellosk said:
Ditto. These types of discussions are best held over a cold Presidente, they become tiresome on a message board.


Who's to say one can't type and sip at the same time? ;)
 

trina

Silver
Jan 3, 2002
2,550
11
0
NY1 said:
Who's to say one can't type and sip at the same time? ;)



Judging by some people's posts, this is probably what is happening. I'd like to think that a sober person would never make up all those "stats" and "facts". In that case, carry on. :classic:
 

rellosk

Silver
Mar 18, 2002
4,170
59
48
trina said:
Judging by some people's posts, this is probably what is happening. I'd like to think that a sober person would never make up all those "stats" and "facts". In that case, carry on. :classic:
Who was it that said 46% of the facts that people quote are made up?

BTW, I was too lazy to look up the quote, so I made up the 46%:)
 

Cleef

Bronze
Feb 24, 2002
1,797
6
0
The bed bugs

ARod has to play for the US. This was in the news - although a much smaller item than his chest pumping hystrionics of "I'm all Dominican" - a couple days later.

For the rest, I like Venezuela too (the reasonable underdog), and they could win just like the DR or US, but those of you who are pumping up their pitching are more than a little off.

A simple 'for instance': None of the proposed starting pitchers is even a number one on their current team.

Secondly, Johan, if you throw out last year's remarkable performance, is a Rule IV pick-up. I'm not knocking the guy, but his sample size is miniscule, and since his improbable run of '04, he's been very pedestrian since.

I'd say only Freddy Garcia has more than 5 years MLB service. The Zambrano's? Good pitchers, but certainly not in the category of a Prior or Clemens - or even Maddux for that matter.

Originally (years ago when the reality of the idea first surfaced) I figured it would be a DR walk through, but the more I consider the reality of it all, I think the US should win. Depth will ultimately be the deciding factor, and as it is, the US has far more to draw from.

One question I'm curious to see answered is if the US will take the competition seriously, or look at it as just another exhibition schedule with different window dressing.

Will they look at this as an opportunity to wrestle the self-anointed "kingdom of baseball" title from the DR? Or will the DR look to affirm its belief as the powerhouse?

Until the rosters are laid out, this posturing as to betting, and who will win and why, is nonsensical.

I hope you all know that this thread keeps Robert awake at night, and doubles his tea intake during the day. lol!
 

rellosk

Silver
Mar 18, 2002
4,170
59
48
Cleef said:
I hope you all know that this thread keeps Robert awake at night, and doubles his tea intake during the day. lol!
I amazed that he hasn't closed this thread, as he has done to many other baseball threads.
 

miguel

I didn't last long...
Jul 2, 2003
5,257
2
0
114
Listen!

DRPAWA said:
I will contend that for a Dominican player to make it to the majors he not only has to be as good as the gringo players but rather he has to be better than most of the other gringo players contending for the position.

I do hope you agree with me Miguel.
Nowhere in any of my posts have I stated that dominican players are not good. There are many, many dominican players that are great. The DR has produced many good players over the years. Who can forget players from yesterday like Juan Marichal, Mateo, Jesus and Felipe Alou, Pedro Guerrero, Ricardo Carty, Julian Javier, Cesar Geronimo, Franklin Taveras(who is still getting paid by the Mets even though he retired many, many moons ago), Mario Guerrero (not that good) and hundreds others.

I do agree with you half way. It's harder for them to make it. But when someone is great, people WILL notice!.

On a side note: What is it with some of you guys that can not carry a topic/debate like adults?. Why is it that if you have a difference of opinion with someone, all of a sudden that person is not sober. Some people state "facts" and 'stats" because they know that in hell they are talking about. Instead of trying to ruin the fricking thread with your stupid and sarcastic comments, why not just stay away from reading or posting in it.
You don't agree with me, fine, state your case, as DRPAWA is doing. If not, why not stay away since you have no "facts" or "stats" to state. I feel that even if I don't like you, I would still would tell you if I think that you are wrong and then state my case. Liking someone has nothing to do with discussing a topic. Give me a break!. Some people!.
 
Last edited:

trina

Silver
Jan 3, 2002
2,550
11
0
miguel said:
On a side note: What is it with some of you guys that can not carry a topic/debate like adults?. Why is it that if you have a difference of opinion with someone, all of a sudden that person is not sober. Some people state "facts" and 'stats" because they know that in hell they are talking about. Instead of trying to ruin the fricking thread with your stupid and sarcastic comments, why not just stay away from reading or posting in it.
You don't agree with me, fine, state your case, as DRPAWA is doing. If not, why not stay away since you have no "facts" or "stats" to state. I feel that even if I don't like you, I would still would tell you if I think that you are wrong and then state my case. Liking someone has nothing to do with discussing a topic. Give me a break!. Some people!.

For future reference, Miguel, try to acknowledge that everything posted on this site is not all about you...I'm sorry you thought I was talking about you, but I wasn't.
 
Last edited:

miguel

I didn't last long...
Jul 2, 2003
5,257
2
0
114
Why!

trina said:
Why would you take what I said as a personal attack against you, Miguel? Feeling insecure about something? For future reference, everything posted on this site is not all about you...
Listen, I was not talking about just me. Other posters were stating "facts" and "stats" also. I could not care less if you are attacking me but when some people are trying to carry on a "conversation" I think that it's inpolite to throw in some stupid remarks about those that are trying to stay "on topic". Guess what followed after your remark?. The topic went nowhere until Cleef posted about it again!. I think that you "know" me a little, but enough to know that if I thought that you were attacking me(only), I would had not taken it sitting down.

All I am saying is repeating something that have been told to me a few times: "don't like what is being said/posted, either challenge the post/opinion or stay way". As simple as that!.

And no, I am not insecure. Fat, ugly and short but not insecure!.

Now, can we stick to the darn thread!!!!!?.

No, Cleef, no PM's needed. I said my peace. Let's talk F'ing baseball now!.
 

Cleef

Bronze
Feb 24, 2002
1,797
6
0
Please

Would the two of you use the PM feature.

In other words - Shut The Phuck Up!
 

toneloc24

Bronze
Mar 8, 2004
628
0
16
What's the world coming to? I agree with Cleef on a lot?

Regarding Venezuela, Carlos Zambrano has been the stud for the Chicago Cubs staff for the past 3 years, even though his W/L record doesn't reflect it. The Cubs just don't score many runs for him. His worst year of the 3 is this year, and he's 7-4 with a 3.42 ERA!!! Check the records. Prior and Wood get the acclaim, but both have missed much of the past 3 seasons between them, rendering them useless as aces.

There's no way in hell you can compare him to Bartolo Colon, Odaliz Perez, Jose Lima, or Pedro Astacio. Same with Freddy Garcia. Then there's K-Rod!!! Throw in Santana, quality pitching or not?

Let's just say A-Rod ISN'T playing altogether. I can't in any way see the Yankees letting him ($26 million/yr), or Jeter ($19.6 million), or Sheffield ($13 million), or Johnson ($16 million/yr) playing in some fantasy series when real money is at stake for 162 games.

Same with Boston with Manny ($22 million) or Ortiz ($5.25 million, yeah shocking) or Schilling ($14.5 million)

Same with St. Louis with Pujols ($11 million) or Rolen ($11.625 million).

Same with Baltimore with Tejada ($11 million) or Sammy Sosa ($17 million).

Same with LA Angels with Vlad ($12.5 million).

These teams aren't gonna invest this kind of money in players and let them risk injury in activities that puts their investments at risk. Pride or not.

And to not be able to talk about baseball on a site that supposed to be about the DR and Dominicans, is like talking about Britain and not being able to mention football (soccer). I'll keep saying that.

Now this thread will really be closed. LOL!!!

Cleef said:
ARod has to play for the US. This was in the news - although a much smaller item than his chest pumping hystrionics of "I'm all Dominican" - a couple days later.

For the rest, I like Venezuela too (the reasonable underdog), and they could win just like the DR or US, but those of you who are pumping up their pitching are more than a little off.

A simple 'for instance': None of the proposed starting pitchers is even a number one on their current team.

Secondly, Johan, if you throw out last year's remarkable performance, is a Rule IV pick-up. I'm not knocking the guy, but his sample size is miniscule, and since his improbable run of '04, he's been very pedestrian since.

I'd say only Freddy Garcia has more than 5 years MLB service. The Zambrano's? Good pitchers, but certainly not in the category of a Prior or Clemens - or even Maddux for that matter.

Originally (years ago when the reality of the idea first surfaced) I figured it would be a DR walk through, but the more I consider the reality of it all, I think the US should win. Depth will ultimately be the deciding factor, and as it is, the US has far more to draw from.

One question I'm curious to see answered is if the US will take the competition seriously, or look at it as just another exhibition schedule with different window dressing.

Will they look at this as an opportunity to wrestle the self-anointed "kingdom of baseball" title from the DR? Or will the DR look to affirm its belief as the powerhouse?

Until the rosters are laid out, this posturing as to betting, and who will win and why, is nonsensical.

I hope you all know that this thread keeps Robert awake at night, and doubles his tea intake during the day. lol!
 

miguel

I didn't last long...
Jul 2, 2003
5,257
2
0
114
Lets wait and see!

Cleef said:
ARod has to play for the US. This was in the news - although a much smaller item than his chest pumping hystrionics of "I'm all Dominican" - a couple days later.

For the rest, I like Venezuela too (the reasonable underdog), and they could win just like the DR or US, but those of you who are pumping up their pitching are more than a little off.


I'd say only Freddy Garcia has more than 5 years MLB service. The Zambrano's? Good pitchers, but certainly not in the category of a Prior or Clemens - or even Maddux for that matter.

One question I'm curious to see answered is if the US will take the competition seriously, or look at it as just another exhibition schedule with different window dressing.
Do you think that "The Boss" will be happy if some of his players play?. I don't think so!.

So you like Venezuela because they are underdogs?. Well, I hate to tell you that they do not have 25 great players to play . Some very good, but not many great ones.

I have to give it to you. 3 years ago, in my opinion, Freddy Garcia had all the "tools" to be a great, great pitcher. What happened, I really don't know. He had it all. He is still young and can rebounce. The talent on that kid is amazing!.

No, it will not be take seriously since many will not be allowed to play. If you were an owner, yould you let your 25m dollars investment play on a tournament where he can get hurt?. I would not, not in this life!.