I am not an expert on wine. I know what I like, and I even know what I am supposed to like. I once had a French girlfriend (from Burgundy) and she told me what I was supposed to like: something called Pouilly-Fuiss?. The first time I referred to ir as "Fussy Pussy" she cracked up. But the joke got old. I will admit, I rather liked it, except for the price. What I like more is a California Zinfandel I think from Beringer, and Argentine Malbec. I have never had a bad bottle of bad wine of any of these. As I say, I know what I like, but of course there are so many different labels this is only useful in a major wine store like Total Wines.
Wine goes bad, they say, when it reacts with the cork. My French girlfriend was actually the widow of a Pied Noir mechanic who had died from (according to her) eating and drinking too much of the wrong stuff. He had a younger brother who bought a country inn in a very small hamlet about 30 kms. north of Pau. Her sister in law was a serious cook, and the brother in law was sort of a Jack of all trades type who had spent the previous three years restoring this place, which had only two rooms for guests. The eventual goal was to expand this to seven rooms. He discovered a trove of ancient vins hidden away somewhere, and on Christmas Eve there was a party and all seventeen of the mobile citizens attended and we must have opened and tried thirty bottles, about half of which were undrinkable, most of them bottled in the 1950's from local estates.
I observe that many Chilean wines use some sort of vinyl corks, which do not seem to impart any flavor to the wine, and will not react with the wine. I should write down which these are, since one cannot tell whether the cork is vinyl until one removes the foil.
I am no wine expert and I have no internet refrences..... just so we are clear.
I manage restaurants so of course got to know my wines.
The term
bouchonn?e is used when a wine is tasted, and does not taste good. The term which refers to the cork is misleading.
2 cases.
First the wine is bad, can be for diffrent reasons ( temperature of stockage, cuve/barrel fouled......), the client will refuse the bottle ( it his right in fr/ch ), the
vigneron ( if like me u buy directly from the producer ) or the
caviste, ie guy who sells wine ( most restaurants will go that route ), will replace the bottle.
Second case, the wine has a faint smell of cork. Some ignorant clients will refuse the wine, most restaurants wont argue. If left a couple of minutes of
oxygenation, the wine will loose the faint smell and be perfect ( well as it is supposed to be ). Some restaurants will
perecipit?e the wine in order not to have this problem. ie tip the bottle, fast into a wine jug ( special jugs for diffrent wines ). It is called
carafer the wine.
If everybody starts using synthetic corks, u can eliminate problem number 2, which is not really a problem.
But it wont solve problem number 1, u will still have turned bad wines.
Also synthetic corks often do not let the wine
breath, essential to age wine correctly.
With the new trend of biodynamic ( bio and often sulfat free )wines, u now get wines with lots of
depot which people mistake for cork, when in fact it is sugar cristilasition......... also u can have gas escape when the bottle is opened. Again this is perfectly in the norm with biodynamics wine.
On a side note, I worked for a wine entertainement buisness( also cheese and coffee ). Taste great wines, quizzes and games involving wine.
One game had 4 dark, opaque glasses. One with white wine, one with red, one with ros?, one with a mix of red and white. Out of a humdred participants, maybe 10 got them right.......... as in food, wine is tasted also by sight....... ( dont believ me ?? Give it a try......).