Gun limit

Status
Not open for further replies.

suarezn

Gold
Feb 3, 2002
5,823
290
0
55
How do you account for the stats from states that have enacted conceal carry permits, and "Castle Hold" laws?

You need to add the stats from both Great Britain and Australia, countries who have recently enacted and enforced draconain gun laws. What about THEIR recent "problems"?

A gun never, ever shot anything.

I suspect we'll disagree on this one.

I believe we do....so let's agree to disagree as this is one of those arguments that could probably never be settled as there's emotion involved which makes us try to ignore the facts. The facts (statistics) are very clear, but again those emotions tend to get in the way...
 

cobraboy

Pro-Bono Demolition Hobbyist
Jul 24, 2004
40,964
936
113
The mentioned US Constitution was referring to self defense, not an assault arsenals.
Sorry, but you are very, very wrong.


gamana said:
I think gun owners like wanna wherever they are from are a danger to the society. Most of those hardcore gun owners are from the US, the world champion of shootings (didn't see that written in the Constitution). I guess the purpose of the 2nd Amendment (self defense) degenerated into a severe society crisis in the US.
I own several guns. I grew up in a "gun" family. Many Americans have. I am a member of the NRA.

If you ever met me (and the millions like me, educated, peaceful, level-headed and proud), you'd realize how terribly wrong your broad brush stereotype is.

And obviously you (and others) have absolutely no clue about the U.S. Constitution. Or law-abiding gun owners.

Ignorance breeds bigotry.
 

cobraboy

Pro-Bono Demolition Hobbyist
Jul 24, 2004
40,964
936
113
I believe we do....so let's agree to disagree as this is one of those arguments that could probably never be settled as there's emotion involved which makes us try to ignore the facts. The facts (statistics) are very clear, but again those emotions tend to get in the way...
No emotion on my side. I'll be happy to match you fact for fact.

Please proceed.

:)
 

aegap

Silver
Mar 19, 2005
2,505
10
0
the problem with the U.S. is that gun ownership has become too much of a federal issue.

My gun plan: almost illegal in the cities (e.g. NYC), mandatory in rural areas (e.g. all of North Dakota), lol. ...complimented by the Chris Rock Plan
 
Last edited:

aegap

Silver
Mar 19, 2005
2,505
10
0
..,why in the ****ing world do private citizens need automatic/semi-automatic AK-47s for? ..they're cool to shoot every time I visit by friend in Cumberland, MD, ..but what that ****?
 

Don Juan

Living Brain Donor
Dec 5, 2003
856
0
0
NRA mentality= people like you.

I am "locked and loaded" to take you on WITH FACTS. Care to put some up for your many statements? Let's go!!!

And, please: what is the "NRA Mentality"? You apologize for insults, and then you go back and start slinging them around again.

CB, Proud Lifetime Member of the NRA, and Sons of the American Revolution

The National Rifle Association is composed of deranged people that'd like to think we're still in the 1800 hundreds when lawlessness in the western territories ran rampant and the law of the gun was king. ....Well, this isn't the 1800's and we now have laws and police to protect us. (such as it is).
What the NRA does (hiding behind the 2nd ammendment), is to encourage the insanity of owning guns for "protection".- "If law-abiding citizens don't have guns, only criminals will have guns"- or something to that affect. That's one of the ridiculous phrases they toss around while ignoring that the overwhelming number of guns used in criminal acts are guns stolen from rightfull owners!
In DC, according to a recent report by the Washington Post, nine out of ten guns recovered from criminals were traced back to a legal owner.
Didn't you know criminals aren't allowed to by guns legaly?? How do you think they come to have them??

Mr Cobraboy, you show me how many people were saved by owning guns, and I'll show you how many were not. You want statistics on the murder rate of gun-happy countries? and those that prohibit them? I can easily get them for you.
I maintain, that if it were not for the Pseudo-patriotic people like yourself, this world would be a much better place to live with less crime, murders, and A-holes.
 

dogstar

New member
Oct 24, 2004
208
6
0
Guns You Can't Own

Is there a limit of guns you may legally own in the Dominican Republic? I have a Berretta .9mm, .380, a Kimber 45, and a Styer-AUG ( although I was told I would not be able to bring my Styer-AUG assault rifle here ). I have noticed many persons here showing there pistols on their belts and shoved in their pants, are shoulder holsters forbidden?

To answer your question, it seems you lost your thread to the gun anti gun crowd, you cannot have a 357 or a 45 , they are for ranking officers during war times. No long guns center fired, except shotguns, 22 rim fired and air rifles ok.
joe
 

cobraboy

Pro-Bono Demolition Hobbyist
Jul 24, 2004
40,964
936
113
I maintain, that if it were not for the Pseudo-patriotic people like yourself, this world would be a much better place to live with less crime, murders, and A-holes.
Thanks for yet another insult Don Juan.

CB is finished with you.

Have a good day.
 

gamana

New member
Apr 24, 2006
225
2
0
cobraboy

The US has the highest rate of shootings in the world, period. The weapons sold to the public there belong to video games.

i am indeed not a specialist of the American Constitution but i know for sure that the intent of the constitution with regards to ownership of weapons was not to transform the US as a shooting playground.

you may take the Fifth on this.
 

cobraboy

Pro-Bono Demolition Hobbyist
Jul 24, 2004
40,964
936
113
i am indeed not a specialist of the American Constitution but i know for sure that the intent of the constitution with regards to ownership of weapons was not to transform the US as a shooting playground.
And you know the "intent", how?

If citizens owned guns, how difficult would it be for a government to impose tyranny? Maybe someone who lost relatives in the holocaust, China or former Soviet Union could answer.

A gun never killed anybody.
 

dogstar

New member
Oct 24, 2004
208
6
0
I live in Silver Spring, just north of the Washington,DC line. It is relatively calm around here with only a few people gunned down each week. In DC, and in nearby Baltimore, however, the situation gets much dire with hundreds of fatalities each year attributed to "gunplay".
It saddens me inmensely to read that another child was in the line of fire and became another victim of the NRA mentality. To those that think you're being protected by guns in the house, you're tragically wrong. It is stunning to count the number of accidental deaths of young children that manage to circumbent the safety measures put in place. You're most likely to be killed by carrying a gun than not. It gives a person a false sense of security thereby taking foolish risks by proclaming to be the meanest SOB in the valley. With some, not all, common sense departs and replaced by bravado, machismo, and a "make my day" attitude a-la Clint Eastwood.
I don't know but I'll find out, how many people fall victim each year to shootings in the US. It must be in the thousands! How tragic is that?

To those that think totting a gun is an absolute necessity, I envite you to compare the murder rate in US to that of Canada. Two similar nations in many, many ways, yet the amazing difference in per-capita deaths due to shootings. There's one essential difference though, one has a liberal policy on gun ownership, the other one does not.

Again I apologize for insulting West Virginians and red necks. Sometimes the birra Moretti has a strange effect on my mind. It makes me think I'm more righteous and smarter, which of course, I'm not. Just don't shoot me! he-he.:paranoid:

You cannot compare Canada and the US murder rates, our populations are too diverse in makeup. Dodley dorights who would walk a 10 miles with a empty soda can to find a trash can verses people who **** in the halls of apartment houses. Now if you want to compare murder by axe or beer bottle, then I think the weight is on the snow people.
joe
 

cobraboy

Pro-Bono Demolition Hobbyist
Jul 24, 2004
40,964
936
113
This issue is like abortion or religion. Polarizing. Not why I come here. Nor do I come here for crass insults.

CB out on this issue.
 
Sep 19, 2005
4,632
91
48
This isnt the forum to discuss american gun ownership or the NRA........and people like Don Juan are so blinded by their blatant ignorance of real facts its a moot point to debate the issue with someone like that.
The mere fact that Washington has the strictist anti gun rules in all of american, yet he admits has an outrageous incidence of gun crime.....goes beyond his intelligence....he just IGNORES facts like that....

The Dominican Republic does not have laws like america.....and even if it did have draconian gun laws... the pervasive use of the good ole boy system, and corruption would prevent its widespread effect.....I have friends who are in the national guard....one because he shoots competitvely, the other...who knows...he never does anything. But he has the privelages of being in the DR national guard...like full automatic weapons...40 caliber pistols silenced rifles .....sniper rifles ect ect......this country is all about who you know or are......if someone has a relative above captian in any branch of the military.....you know they can have rifles and 45 caliber pistols.........I have posted to this fact before......so it would be very hard to pin down what someone can REALLY have........and in the end a man with common sense will always be better off armed.....especially in this country......at the worst he spends a little time in jail.....and lives...even less ...maybe maybe...he pays a few grand to get out of a bind......BUT he lives........( or at least gives himself a chance)


Old don juan wants to preach to us about our gun mentailty when he uses his excess at drinking for an excuse to thinking straight himself.......yeah .....good move

bob
 

Rick Snyder

Silver
Nov 19, 2003
2,321
2
0
As some of you wish to talk about statistics I?ve compiled some links for you to look at to help you in your pixxing contest on who is the biggest meanie;

NationMaster - Statistics > Murders by country
NationMaster - Statistics > Murders with firearms by country
NationMaster - Statistics > Murders with firearms (per capita) by country
DEATH BY MURDER
Bureau of Justice Statistics Firearms and Crime Statistics
Bureau of Justice Statistics Crimes Committed with Firearms
Murder - Crime in the United States 2004


Things I came across on the web;
?
More children choke to death on pencils and drown in buckets of water, than die from the mishandling of a gun. ?

"Wherever "Shall Issue" concealed carry laws have been adopted, crime involving firearms has decreased. Sometimes, this decrease has been dramatic, sometimes the decrease has been slight, but crime has almost never risen after "Shall Issue" concealed carry laws were adopted.?

?according to the FBI's Uniform Crime Reports, the states that allow lawful Citizens to carry concealed are the states with the lowest number of violent crimes.?

?For example, the state of Vermont, where one only has to have a clean record and be at least 21 years old to carry a concealed gun, has 22 times fewer incidence of violent crime per 100,000 Citizens than Washington D.C., which has had a total ban on firearms since the mid-seventies.?

?1. 31.09 murders are committed with firearms everyday.
2. 6844.62 times a day, firearms are used for self-defense.
3. Firearms are used 220.15 times more for self-defense than for murder.?

The truth is everything on the issue of firearms.

Let me leave you with a couple quotes;

"25 States allow anyone to buy a gun, strap it on, and walk down the street with no permit of any kind: some say it's crazy. However, four out of five US murders are committed in the other half of the country: so who's crazy?"
-- Andrew Ford

"They that would give up essential liberty for a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-- Benjamin Franklin

Rick
 

aegap

Silver
Mar 19, 2005
2,505
10
0
informal fallacies (both sides of the argument employ it)

"25 States allow anyone to buy a gun, strap it on, and walk down the street with no permit of any kind: some say it's crazy. However, four out of five US murders are committed in the other half of the country: so who's crazy?" -- Andrew Ford

Hey Andrew Ford, maybe those other 25 states should allow the same. It would reduce crime a lot, woudn't it?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.