Like Dolores @ DR1, PCBR also holds sentimental memories for me as well. My husband and I honeymooned in the DR for two weeks; first week in Samana and second at PCBR. By far our week in Samana was more fun, even though we were at a much smaller resort. It was the mixture of the hotel, which was just beautiful, and the natural beauty of Samana. We also did a lot of exploring around the peninsula, thus that first week was much more memorable than PCBR.
Now, PCBR IS a very nice resort. The staff there works very hard and are always willing to please. From a comparison point, the rooms at PC were not as nice as we had anticipated, especailly for a 4 star resort (we were in the rooms located in the 3 story buildings). The rooms at Gran Bahia were much nicer. The food was better at PCBR, but my husband did get sick for about a day. Service overall was attentive, EXCEPT at the beach bar and the Italian restaurant (Mama Venezia was it?). The layout of the resort is nice, we especially liked the rooms in the little villas. No room is too far from the restaurants. Though this is very complete resort and big as well, it never felt huge. We took the walking tour of the mangroves (free) and it was great!
Don't expect luxury here. Do expect attentive service and friendliness. Would we recommend the resort? Definetely. I have heard that they improved many things about the place - that's nice. Would we go back? Yes, but we'd like to try other places first, like Club Dominicus or Casa del Mar.
Natasha