My attempt to get Residencia Definitiva not going well

cobraboy

Pro-Bono Demolition Hobbyist
Jul 24, 2004
40,976
945
113
Question for the group:

Under what obligation is a foreigner in the DR obligated to abide by local laws?
 

Dr_Taylor

New member
Oct 18, 2017
351
2
0
I seem to remember 6 months of residency was the threshold....
If married to a Dominican
I believe that it is longer, now. In any event, this, yes this, is exactly why I suggest that folk choose capable counsel. As someone who once worked in government, I have met too many government workers who did not know the law, regulations, or what they were doing.
 
Last edited:

Matilda

RIP Lindsay
Sep 13, 2006
5,485
338
63
Constitución De La República Dominicana
SECCIÓN III - Del Régimen De Extranjería
Artículo 25 - Régimen De Extranjería
Artículo 25 Artículo 25.- Régimen de extranjería. Extranjeros y extranjeras tienen en la República Dominicana los mismos derechos y deberes que los nacionales, con las excepciones y limitaciones que establecen esta Constitución y las leyes; en consecuencia: 1) No pueden participar en actividades políticas en el territorio nacional, salvo para el ejercicio del derecho al sufragio de su país de origen; 2) Tienen la obligación de registrarse en el Libro de Extranjería, de acuerdo con la ley; 3) Podrán recurrir a la protección diplomática después de haber agotado los recursos y procedimientos ante la jurisdicción nacional, salvo lo que dispongan los convenios internacionales.

In other words exactly the same obligation as Dominicans according to the Constitution but cannot take part in political activities.

Matilda
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
44,891
7,341
113
I believe that it is longer, now. In any event, this, yes this, is exactly why I suggest that folk choose capable counsel. As someone who once worked in government, I have met too many government workers who did not know the law, regulations, or what they were doing.

In order to become a citizen, I have read comments from a number of posters that went the route of DR citizenship that it is strongly discouraged to use a lawyer to be naturalized. They much prefer you to do it without one. I certainly will take the non-lawyer approach as I did with my latest regularization of residency.
 

Matilda

RIP Lindsay
Sep 13, 2006
5,485
338
63
In order to become a citizen, I have read comments from a number of posters that went the route of DR citizenship that it is strongly discouraged to use a lawyer to be naturalized. They much prefer you to do it without one. I certainly will take the non-lawyer approach as I did with my latest regularization of residency.

That was certainly correct when I did mine. Maybe it is just the marriage route as they wanted to meet my husband, they wanted to talk to me and not a lawyer. I did use a friend in the capital to hand in some additional paperwork but apart from that I did it all myself.

Matilda
 

william webster

Rest In Peace WW
Jan 16, 2009
30,246
4,333
113
I used one.... and she has done many others....

I had no interest in weekly trips to the offices to track paperwork & progress.

4 months -- and I should be in...end of Nov to end of March....exam to ceremony

For me - they skipped the interview - he was too busy

I had property, cars , 10 yrs...... seemed to be enough
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
44,891
7,341
113
I used one.... and she has done many others....

I had no interest in weekly trips to the offices to track paperwork & progress.

4 months -- and I should be in...end of Nov to end of March....exam to ceremony

For me - they skipped the interview - he was too busy

I had property, cars , 10 yrs...... seemed to be enough

If it indeed takes weekly trips to Santo Domingo to become a citizen, that might cause me to reconsider my methods.
 

william webster

Rest In Peace WW
Jan 16, 2009
30,246
4,333
113
As you can read elsewhere here
Things won’t happen by themselves... someone needs to push the file along

They lost my stuff...supposedly...TWICE
They don’t call to tell you that...
When you follow up... then it surfaces ... their errors

Get a professional....my advice
 

Matilda

RIP Lindsay
Sep 13, 2006
5,485
338
63
If it indeed takes weekly trips to Santo Domingo to become a citizen, that might cause me to reconsider my methods.

It does not take weekly trips at all. You go once to hand in your paperwork and pay the exorbitant fee of RD$1,500. You then return to take your examination and interview and then back again to be sworn in. When you hand your papers in, find out the name of your case handler and their email. Then email them to check progress - they usually do answer the phone as well as emails - of course has to be done in Spanish. If they ask for one or two additional bits of paperwork then get a friend to hand it in for you. Now the issue of the bogus Interpol report has disappeared they aim to be done in 6 months from receipt of file to swearing in.

Matilda
 

Dr_Taylor

New member
Oct 18, 2017
351
2
0
As you can read elsewhere here
Things won’t happen by themselves... someone needs to push the file along

They lost my stuff...supposedly...TWICE
They don’t call to tell you that...
When you follow up... then it surfaces ... their errors

Get a professional....my advice
I cannot agree more. DGM lost one of my documents once while I was outside the RD. The firm simply handled the matter and alerted me to the delay. Personally, I prefer not to interact with governments, unless I must.
 

Dr_Taylor

New member
Oct 18, 2017
351
2
0
Now the issue of the bogus Interpol report has disappeared they aim to be done in 6 months from receipt of file to swearing in.

Matilda
I heard this. As I understand it, unless a government is looking for you, an individual will not trigger an Interpol alert. Moreover, if you are living in the country with permanent residency and staying out of trouble, DGM and Internal Security should not need an Interpol check.
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
44,891
7,341
113
As you can read elsewhere here
Things won’t happen by themselves... someone needs to push the file along

They lost my stuff...supposedly...TWICE
They don’t call to tell you that...
When you follow up... then it surfaces ... their errors

Get a professional....my advice


If they lost my apostilled birth certificate and/or FBI report, etc., I would not continue the process by getting those documents again. It would not be worth doing that again.

I just checked a service that Matilda mentioned to me. Just to get an FBI report was several hundred dollars using them. Each of the several steps was another $50 or more US.


It does not take weekly trips at all. You go once to hand in your paperwork and pay the exorbitant fee of RD$1,500. You then return to take your examination and interview and then back again to be sworn in. When you hand your papers in, find out the name of your case handler and their email. Then email them to check progress - they usually do answer the phone as well as emails - of course has to be done in Spanish. If they ask for one or two additional bits of paperwork then get a friend to hand it in for you. Now the issue of the bogus Interpol report has disappeared they aim to be done in 6 months from receipt of file to swearing in.

Matilda

That I expect and can deal with myself.

I cannot agree more. DGM lost one of my documents once while I was outside the RD. The firm simply handled the matter and alerted me to the delay. Personally, I prefer not to interact with governments, unless I must.

I like lawyers even a little bit less than DR government agencies. It is a close contest.

Either I do it myself using notaries and translators when necessary or I won't do it at all.
 

william webster

Rest In Peace WW
Jan 16, 2009
30,246
4,333
113
We get the message Windy....

The only encouragement I can offer is that it seems all cases go differently.
You may get lucky....think Clint Eastwood......
I hope you do.

If frustration irks you - get ready.....
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
44,891
7,341
113
We get the message Windy....

The only encouragement I can offer is that it seems all cases go differently.
You may get lucky....think Clint Eastwood......
I hope you do.

If frustration irks you - get ready.....

Oh, trust me, I fully understand why the people in Migracion are behind bullet proof glass. Last time I was there a lawyer overheard my plight with the idiotic woman agent told me to calm down and I would only make matters worse.

If they were to lose my documents at the Department of the Interior and Police and need such things again like a birth certificate, divorce decree and death certificate with an apostille, legalized and translated, I would simply stop trying for citizenship.

Very soon I get to see if they really have my new residency card at Migracion and if it is for one and "temporary" or four years and "permanent". That is the current quest.
 
Last edited:

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
44,891
7,341
113
Matilda mentioned a company called Expat Services that offers getting an FBI background check in the DR.

The fingerprint office is in Santo Domingo. The charge is $100 US just for taking fingerprints and they are only open in the morning which means I would have to travel to Santo Domingo the night before just to get a set of fingerprints taken. After paying $100 US for that the charges just add up:

Cost of fingerprint plus fees - US$100.00 (payable to Expat Services)
Overnight shipping to the United States - US$70.00 (payable to Expat Services)
Cost of FBI - US$39.95 plus US$9 for each additional copy (payable to FBI channeler via credit card)
Shipping to address in the United States - US$0 - US$40 (payable to FBI channeler via credit card)


We do not provide the apostille service directly. We refer you to a company dedicated to apostilling documents in the United States. You will need to have someone of trust send the document to this company. This company in turn will mail it to you in the Dominican Republic.

Apostille services - US$200.00 per document (payable to Apostille company in US)


Once you receive the apostilled documents you should send back to me for translating.

Translations - US$15.00 per page (payable to Expat Services)


Since your documents are to be used to obtain Dominican citizenship all documents must be legalized at the Dominican District Attorney's office. In order to be able to legalize each documents we must have the original and the document must be apostilled.

Legalization at Dominican District Attorney´s office - US$30.00 per document (payable to Expat Services)

A bargain at over $400 US just for the FBI report, it is not, but yes it is an option if I never wanted to leave my house. I just noted a credit card is needed. I don't use credit cards in the DR (the FBI channeler is probably in the US, so that might not be an issue).

I think I can do all of that myself at considerably less cost. And that is only one document needed from the US for citizenship. There are at least two more from sources on opposite sides of the country.
 
Last edited:

william webster

Rest In Peace WW
Jan 16, 2009
30,246
4,333
113
Oh, trust me, I fully understand why the people in Migracion are behind bullet proof glass. Last time I was there a lawyer overheard my plight with the idiotic woman agent told me to calm down and I would only make matters worse.

If they were to lose my documents at the Department of the Interior and Police and need such things again like a birth certificate, divorce decree and death certificate with an apostille, legalized and translated, I would simply stop trying for citizenship.

Very soon I get to see if they really have my new residency card at Migracion and if it is for one and "temporary" or four years and "permanent". That is the current quest.

Thank you Windy -
for starting my day with a laugh.....

hahaha........hilarious
 

chico bill

Silver
May 6, 2016
14,048
8,008
113
Oh, trust me, I fully understand why the people in Migracion are behind bullet proof glass. Last time I was there a lawyer overheard my plight with the idiotic woman agent told me to calm down and I would only make matters worse.

If they were to lose my documents at the Department of the Interior and Police and need such things again like a birth certificate, divorce decree and death certificate with an apostille, legalized and translated, I would simply stop trying for citizenship.

Very soon I get to see if they really have my new residency card at Migracion and if it is for one and "temporary" or four years and "permanent". That is the current quest.

Soon they will make it too unpleasant and people will loose interest in continually fighting the process of ever-changing regulations and even visitors, as tourists, may loose interest in coming.
The one thing they did for tourists that was positive is adding the tourist $10 fee to the airline tickets instead of standing in line at the airport.

But at some point there will be enough straws to break people's will.

As B. Kliban said "The Wagon of Love Breaks Down Under the Baggage of Life"
 

windeguy

Platinum
Jul 10, 2004
44,891
7,341
113
Soon they will make it too unpleasant and people will loose interest in continually fighting the process of ever-changing regulations and even visitors, as tourists, may loose interest in coming.
The one thing they did for tourists that was positive is adding the tourist $10 fee to the airline tickets instead of standing in line at the airport.

But at some point there will be enough straws to break people's will.

As B. Kliban said "The Wagon of Love Breaks Down Under the Baggage of Life"

I don't see any issues with the vast majority of tourists. They come for less than 30 days.
It is only after 30 days for snowbirds that needs work regarding snow bird visas that may never exist.

As for residency, it is much more difficult than before.

As for naturalization, I have yet to determine how easy it will be in my case. The list is long and some items may be more difficult to get than I care to attempt. I will be researching that starting this week.
 

chico bill

Silver
May 6, 2016
14,048
8,008
113
I don't see any issues with the vast majority of tourists. They come for less than 30 days.
It is only after 30 days for snowbirds that needs work regarding snow bird visas that may never exist.

As for residency, it is much more difficult than before.

As for naturalization, I have yet to determine how easy it will be in my case. The list is long and some items may be more difficult to get than I care to attempt. I will be researching that starting this week.
True the tourists still come but prices are starting to make the DR a little less welcoming. Maybe the snow birds become less than 30 days. Maybe they need another Gringo round up to really drive the snowbirds away.

Everything has a beginning a middle and a peak and a decline.

Not sure where we are now, but it is for sure it's near the peak. Numbers for Punta Cana need to be watched. If they decline that could be the canary in the coal mine.

Sent from my SM-A530F using Tapatalk
 

malko

Campesino !! :)
Jan 12, 2013
5,673
1,458
113
Selfishly, I am more than OK with less expats and less tourists....... drive those prices back down ;) ;)