I came here for the first time, around 20 years ago... and even then the hotel in Sosua told me it was very unsafe to leave the hotel, unless it was on one of their organised tours...
Now I was, and still am, a very disobedient boy, and if they tell me I cannot do something, I'm sure to try it... So, at that time, and even with some pushing, I left the hotel, rented myself a moto (not concho), and went for a ride... yes, I got picked up by some guy offering himself as a guide for the day... had a great day, for a few hundred pesos... and an incredible sunburn on my arms and hands (when I got of the bike, I could not bend them... lol)...
Did I ever feel unsafe???... heck no... the guide did a perfect job... was polite... saved me a some bucks because of getting drinks at local prices, and not gringo prices, and was worth every peso...
The fact is, and that is the one CB is referring to, I believe... is that at the moment the DR in general, and especially the NC is described by travel agents as very unsafe and dangerous... killing tourism very effectively...
On top of that, the NC is becoming known as the sex tourism place to go to as a dirty old man/woman..., and to be honest, I am embarassed as European, when I take a flight back or forth... all you hear is about their "conquests" (Belgians, Dutch, Germans, Anglo...) and the high disregard they have about their "women"...
Is this the reality???... Probably not... what is a fact though is that the locals on the NC become less and less friendly towards tourists... (and I cannot really blame them, as they are treated with disrespect, and the kind of tourists they are getting are the ones showing how much money they have)... another fact nevertheless is that, as a foreigner, you are proposed several times on a visit on Sosua beach f.e. (I was there a couple of weeks ago, with my wife, and 2 female friends, on a visit from Belgium, ordered some drinks from one of the many bars, and when my wife and friends were enjoying the sea was asked by the waiter if I would enjoy some female company... when I declined politely, he asked whether I would prefer a boy... hmmmm)
Another friend of ours who visited us 2 weeks ago, and female and 26 years of age, had to convince her extremely worried parents that she was staying with friends (and her parents knew us...) so we could prevent her from being murdered, kidnapped, raped, etc..., and this was info about the DR her parents got from the internet...
I think it is time Sosua, Cabarete, POP, BC, and probably a lot of other cities at the coast, wake up... and realise that this small bunch of bad apples, destroys the tourism industry...
It does not matter what reality is... and it is the same all over the world... if you come here as a tourist, showing the necessary respect and courtesy to the locals, you will have a great time here, and be treated friendly and respectfully... if you come here as a tourist, waving the big bucks around, and being disrespectfull of local customs, you will become a target...
The sad reality is, that tourism and its income depends on the way you are described by the travel agents and by the government websites, and the DR is not doing a good job, as far as those descriptions are concerned...
We know differently... but then again we live here...
My 2 cents worth... the DR tourism industry does have a problem, and will have to deal with it soon...