Tragedy in Santiago; policeman accused of accidentally killing a child

bob saunders

Platinum
Jan 1, 2002
33,705
7,106
113
dr1.com
This incident took place about a 5 minutes walk from where I live.
Dozens of people witnessed what happened.
Loud music played from people's cars during the parades is normal.
During the last 11 years I've never seen anyone complain about it or the PN pay any attention to it
during the Carnival celebrations, This is definitely a first.
The PN have a real problem.
Many of them are accustomed to the old way of policing especially the
one's who've been on the force prior to 2020. I wouldn't be surprised if
it comes out later the officer who fired these shots is from the Valerio detachment
as they have a reputation for being a little trigger happy.



The cop has been in the force for 7 years, so not a rookie.
 

drstock

Silver
Oct 29, 2010
5,207
2,783
113
Cabarete
Personally I never did understand how people get macho when their wife and kids are around. I mean I get it, you don't want to be "backed down" and have set a "poor example" or to "not look like the man" in front of your family but it's a huge liability. When and/or if I would ever be in public with any hypothetical women or children of mine I'd choose to play the alert and ready yet chill and non-confrontational role. Fight, flight or freeze - I choose flight in that situation. I mean you have the most important people in your life present alongside you and you choose to become involved in a potentially violent situation with someone who may or may not be armed? It's basically like being responsible for VIPs and instigating or IN ANY WAY becoming confrontational or responding with like energy to a confrontational situation.

The proper move is to GTFO of there - posthaste and if you're the type that can't let something go then you go back later and handle the situation to your liking, alone or along with other allied combatants. But you don't become involved in or allow the escalation of conflict, of any sort, when you've got your VIPs present.
I would say that the macho "never back down" attitude is pretty common among Dominicans. Maybe even more so when showing off to the kids.
 

Kipling333

Bronze
Jan 12, 2010
2,528
831
113
I have just looked again at the video showing the young boy just having been shot and slumped on the wall just outside the shop. Many many people close by and many police who did nothing for the young boy and then the distraught father is bundled into a police van . The young police look all to be in their twenties but only the shooter had his face half masked. The music was from further down the street. The scuffle was nothing and another man was mainly involved, not the father although he was there.
 

Big

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2019
6,077
5,257
113
No matter what the provocation was, and playing loud music during a carnival seems harmless during the day, the firing of a pistol 4 times into a group of people seems to me criminal and barbaric. The Dominican people will now have even less respect for the police than before,if that is possible. There is another video and some photos that I have seen that show the Policeman with his face half covered.
Maybe it is a result of the harsh days living under police and army brutality during the Trujillo days , but in my opinion, Dominicans do not like to be pushed around by aggressive police behaviour .
undereducated and unsophisticated people have a problem with authority. My manliness is not called into question because a uniformed individual told me to turn down the radio or directed me to turn around because the road is closed. I respect the police.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JD Jones

Facepalm Supreme

Active member
Dec 29, 2022
190
174
43
Santo Domingo
The police should be respected when they behave respectably.

In some places police can be/are like firemen. In other places they act like Gestapo/criminals.

In general I don't argue with people who are armed. If I disagree I go someplace where they aren't. If they come to my inner sanctum with violent intentions and there is no opportunity for diplomacy and I have few/no other options I will defend myself with force but it's always best to fight with the mind instead of the force of arms.

Arguing with people who are armed is a bad practice. Whether they are the police or not. There are other, better options/courses of action.
 

Big

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2019
6,077
5,257
113
I too guess I'm old school whereas I take all under consideration:1) perhaps alcohol may have played a part? imagine someone having the gall to play loud music on a weekend day at a festival no less 2) approaching an individual in a crowd where it can easily escalate to an unwelcomed situation and not having the wherewithal to deescalate and or seek out other more serious infractions.3) probably most paramount ,having said officer prove "quien es mas macho" in front of your kid is a no holds barred "come at me bro" scenario if there ever was one.I am a firm believer that respect is reciprocal. I've been in situations where I have been cordial to law enforce and have had traffic fines waived off, but I have also had situations where no matter the amount of diplomacy I displayed it was in any way a deterrent to the situation.

I don't in anyway see the dad as an innocent bystander and do acknowledge his part, but much too often we are told that compliance = safety when in all reality we've chosen to ignore tangible video proof!
the Police are tasked with keeping law and order. Challenging them is more telling of the citizen than the P.D.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JD Jones

CristoRey

Welcome To Wonderland
Apr 1, 2014
13,876
10,034
113

The main reason I posted these videos is for people to see how the "authorities" respond when a child gets shot at one of the country's largest outdoor fevistals in broad daylight.

You can all watch the videos and judge for yourselves whether or not their actions were appropriate. It's certainly something some of you may want to take into consideration prior to attending outdoor events with your children in the future.
 

Facepalm Supreme

Active member
Dec 29, 2022
190
174
43
Santo Domingo
the Police are tasked with keeping law and order. Challenging them is more telling of the citizen than the P.D.
You really believe that is their charge?

The police are an armed group who are paid. They are charged with following the orders of those who pay their salaries. And as much as we might want to pretend it is "the taxpayers" those are not the people who set the budget nor oversee the distribution of funding.
 

Big

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2019
6,077
5,257
113
The problem Mr Big is that maybe the people in that street of Santiago are under educated and unsophisticated as are the majority of Dominicans.
well certainly at a Carnival celebration that doesn't have any real cultural significance here, other than a reason to get drunk and pick pocket people.
 

Big

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2019
6,077
5,257
113
You really believe that is their charge?

The police are an armed group who are paid. They are charged with following the orders of those who pay their salaries. And as much as we might want to pretend it is "the taxpayers" those are not the people who set the budget nor oversee the distribution of funding.
if you don't believe their job is to protect life and property, Go down to the Zona Colonial. They tolerate almost zero crime.
 

CristoRey

Welcome To Wonderland
Apr 1, 2014
13,876
10,034
113
well certainly at a Carnival celebration that doesn't have any real cultural significance here, other than a reason to get drunk and pick pocket people.
They basically left a young child to die and the PN who fired the shots left scene immediately afterwards according to witnesses. Not much cultural significance in that either I suppose.
 

bob saunders

Platinum
Jan 1, 2002
33,705
7,106
113
dr1.com
The problem Mr Big is that maybe the people in that street of Santiago are under educated and unsophisticated as are the majority of Dominicans.
Well the family live in Cienfuegos, a fairly bad barrio. The street where it happened is a commercial street.
 

Big

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2019
6,077
5,257
113
They basically left a young child to die and the PN who fired the shots left scene immediately afterwards according to witnesses. Not much cultural significance in that either I suppose.
it could of all been avoided. It goes like this. "Yes, officer I understand." " I will comply." That is the example that any responsible parent would display.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Squat and CristoRey

CristoRey

Welcome To Wonderland
Apr 1, 2014
13,876
10,034
113
it could of all been avoided. It goes like this. "Yes, officer I understand." " I will comply." That is the example that any responsible parent would display.
Officer could have easily walked up with a hand shake and instead of barking orders as well. I've been here long enough to have seen both types of approaches. One works a lot better than the other.
 

FF1

Well-known member
Dec 17, 2022
544
675
93
DR
The thing is that in most cases the cops come to take the speaker away not just to tell you to turn the music down, and then when you go to the station to get your speaker back you gotta give them money. It's a racket.
 

Kipling333

Bronze
Jan 12, 2010
2,528
831
113
The boy was not near his father.. In the amateur video, the policeman had an altercation with a man and then the father became involved but this was on the street ..the boy and many other people were on the footpath away from the incident ..the four bullets fired by the policeman could have killed any of the people in that street . There was absolutely no need for the policeman to draw his gun because there were other police in the street to assist him. All is shown on a video.
 

CristoRey

Welcome To Wonderland
Apr 1, 2014
13,876
10,034
113
Story has definitely gained some traction. Wondering if it will be picked up by the international news organizations now that this Sunday's activities have been cancelled.

 
  • Like
Reactions: JD Jones