In the DR, the Spanish handled everything differently. They let the slaves bring their rice and beans and music and religions and mixed it into their society. However, they had a system set up where the whiter you were meant the higher your position would be in society. The mixed people which would be most of society would be at the middle of the pyramid. This led to the DR putting Haiti at the bottom because they tend to be less white. Also, they had the classic Spanish pride put into the DR which led to such great pride in being from the DR and not being very prideful of having African roots all over the society. The truth is that the DR has closer roots in their culture to Africa than the African Americans do just like the rest of the Caribbean does. Many of even the white people on the island have a black grandparent or great grandparent.
Did you know that by the time slavery was abolished in the Dominican Republic, the liberation applied to a minority of the population?
Did you know that by the mid-1600s, most of the population lived as free men, despite being mulatto?
Did you know that the actual slavery that was practiced in the DR for most of its colonial history, was based on cattle ranching and the slaves themselves lived as if they were freed men, given the nature of their work?
I bet you didn't knew that.
The extreme poverty of the colony explains why the institutions, including racial institutions, were not able to be maintained here; unlike in other parts of the Spanish empire that were wealthier. This is also the main reason for why the mixed race population became a majority by the end of the 1600s. The breakdown in the economic well being of the people caused most to depend on their neighbors, regardless what their race was or whether they were of slave origin or not. Most former slaves were left to their own devices and most became subsistence farmers and free for all practical purposes. As people depended on each other for their survival, the newer generation began to mix and before anyone knew it, Dominican society became a mulatto society. The percentages have fluctuated since, but this country has never been anything other than a mulatto-majority society since then.
This is very different from the history of other places, including Cuba and Haiti; which can be considered to be "right there." Different histories produces different results.
It is true that there is more African influence in Dominican culture and in the rest of the Spanish Caribbean than among African Americans, but it still a minor part of the culture. For a person arriving from the US, the African culture among Dominicans appears huge, but that is only by perspective.
If we were to segment everything that makes up culture, it becomes clear that the African component is minor.
For example:
Language: It seems that less than 5% (and this is probably quite generous to begin with) of words in Dominican Spanish, are of African origin. Most non-Spanish words used in the Dominican dialect are actually of Taino origin.
Architecture: Mostly European/Taino and more recently, American and International influences. Africa is not quite visible here either.
Food: There is a greater input of African elements in many Dominican dishes than there is in the language or the architecture, but its still minor. Mang? comes from Africa, but most Dominican dishes quite simply don't have much of Africa in them. If anything, most Dominican dishes are mostly of Spanish origin.
Clothing: Its true that American influence is much more visible here, albeit the average Dominican is much more conscious about his/her fashion sense and, as a result, tend to dress nicer than Americans even for simple things such as going to supermarket. However, traditional Dominican fashion has been 100% of European origin. Africa simply has no presence in this.
We can keep disecting the culture and the only thing that will come to light is that Europe and Taino influences are greater in most aspects than the African, and in many areas Africa is not even present.
There are three things that the African influence is obvious among Dominicans, albeit almost always as a minor component.
1. Music, especially popular music. Its not African in nature a nor is it dominated by the African influence, but the influence is strong enough to be noticed.
2. Religion, not so much the formal part but the beliefs in
brujos and other nonsense (to me its nonsense.)
3. Genetics, although the average Dominican is much more mixed than a typical African American, and this makes the typical Dominican look different from even the typical African American. This, I have discovered, varies greatly within the US. In some parts of the US, Dominicans may not be as distinguished from African Americans while in most areas, there is a clear difference in appearance, usually due to greater European admixture among Dominicans.
Beyond those aspects, the African component is few and far between and this is what we Dominicans mean when we say that we don't have much African influences. We see the whole picture, not enlarge the parts that have a visible African influence while ignoring most aspects of our culture.