So you feel that a woman who cooks, cleans, does the household shopping etc. should have no personal money? If her shoes wear out she should be barefoot?
What she is doing has value. If this is a relationship rather than an economic arrangement, she should be appreciated.
I was asking questions based on the number or phrase "I give her $1000" as being a real number. The OP said it wasnt a real number, just a hypothetical. His point was he gives this woman money to manage the household and she manages it well. You make of it what you want to. I have drawn my conclusion.
But...he never said if she was working or not.
Who cares what I
feel? What
I think is if she needs personal money she needs a job. "If her shoes wear out should be barefoot?" If she is an
'ama de casa' what does she need shoes for? Where does she have to go she cant make it there in flip-flops? Where does she have to go, in any event, where she needs to make a grand ballroom entrance? I think the person personally earning the money is the only person who deserves personal money. She is just cooking the food and so on. Dont make it sound like she MacGyver'd him a jacuzzi from 6 ice cream sandwiches and a book of matches.
We are not in the intricate workings of their life to know if this is a relationship OR an economic arrangement. In either case, there are presently more upsides than downsides for both parties. Only time will tell if the cake baked well.