Thank you all very much for your responses! On one hand, I was truly surprised, but on the other hand, I had somewhat expected the situation to play out this way.
It seems that most participants on this forum are expats who have entirely different ideas about the ideal car compared to the majority of tourists. It’s also clear that people live in different parts of the island, each with its own nuances, but I’m surprised that no one has spoken in favor of compact cars.
Based on my experience as a resident of the Dominican Republic, I agree with those who voted for 4x4 vehicles, as they are versatile. While most Dominicans prefer pickups like the Dodge Ram, which can be used on their ranches, I would still choose the Jeep Cherokee. In my opinion, a car should not only have good off-road capabilities but also be comfortable inside. For example, in my Dodge Ram, the back seats are not the most comfortable for passengers, and if I were to buy a pickup again, I’d go with the Toyota Tundra.
From our experience as a car rental company, I can say that more than 80% of rentals are for small, compact cars. I can also say from personal experience that for living in Punta Cana and Bavaro, a compact car (like Kia Picanto) is the best choice if you need to make frequent trips throughout the day. As a tourist, I’ve tried to rent a Jeep Wrangler several times, but for some reason, the prices for them are sky-high. So if I’m traveling somewhere towards Samaná or Barahona, I try to rent something with good ground clearance, ideally a Jeep Cherokee, but possibly another SUV.