I just got a deal from Europcar for five days rental with insurance, (tiny Hyndai compact with auto / a/c), for about $200. Pick up at Puerto Plata Airport.
Is that with full insurance (CDW, tires, windshield, etc.)? If so that is a good deal for this time of year. The five day rental charge is for you having the car five days and paying four days rental or is it paying for five days rental.
Do you have a link as I would like to compare prices with my current reservation with Avis.