Times have changed.to clarify, your client said the 5 year rule applies to everyone?
It seems that G was able to bring an older car using the residency provision. Could be that times/rules have changed since he did it.
Maybe G can clarify when he was able to do it. That may clear any confusion.
I brought in a 15-passenger 2001 Econolone E350 in 2008. The latest "legal" year for importation at the time was 2002. I had to pay a 20% penalty to Adaunas. I was OK with that because the van was in excellent condition (still is.)
I inquired recently about paying the penalty for an older van once again, and was told that under no circumstances would that be possible, period, the vehicle would be confiscated at the port without any warning or questions.