Despite the......
And just last week a new Italian restaurant opened in the park across from Banco Popular, it is called "Ottimo"
They have an inside dining room and casual seating as well as an outside dining area and pool. Although I haven't eaten there yet, I took some photos this morning as they were just opening up. It looks much nicer in person, they were just opening for the day so I really couldn't take any good pictures.
Hopefully they will do well.
I ate there the other evening. FANTASTIC! Whoever designed the place did an absolutely superb job. Contemporary and classy. Smooth jazz / R&B playing at a level that enhances conversation rather than overpowers it.
Bilingual staff that had obviously received good training.
A classic Italian menu arranged by courses.
Excellent food.
Great value.
We had two appetizers, two entrees, two desserts, and 4 mixed drinks. Total bill was less than 2000 pesos.
I commented on how good the garlic bread was (grilled poolside by your table) and they brought another plate of it.
The tiramisu was huge. (I had the classic version. I'll be going back to try the Amareto version).
Looked like they were well staffed and could have easily handled 20 or more arriving at the same time without a major service disruption.
We didn't try any of the happy hour specials (3-9pm), but I'd go back just to sit around the pool and enjoy the 350 peso pitchers of mojitos! (And I recognize that pool - I did my recertification dive training in it about 6-7 years ago with the now closed "Scuba Elite").
I'd rate this place almost the equal of Casa Venteuno. And the only reason I say "almost" is because C21 had a more eclectic menu, while Ottimo appears to be strictly Italian. But Ottimo has the advantage of being within walking distance and is a much better value than Casa21.
I really hope it survives to high season and then prospers for years to come. And I hope the night we were there is not representative of how it will do. Only one other table (of the 15+) in the poolside dining area was occupied. And I didn't see any customers in the front room while entering or leaving.
Which leads me to another "issue". I consider myself fairly knowledgeable about the area. Yet the only way I knew about this place was by reading NY-DR Commmuters post. I'm not a "marketing guy", but there has to be ways to get the info out.
Do yourself a favor and give them a try.
(Full disclosure: My wife's sisters cousin once dated a guy whose nephews friend used to deliver the newspaper to the owners grandfather). (;-)