I worked for Hotel Gran Bahia in Samana for a number of years, starting when the hotel ope The hotel was built with the idea of attracting very wealthy tourists from any where in the world. When the hotel opened, it figured it would need 1/3 occupancy to break even, given the rates it was charging.
The owners were not willing to take the time necessary to develop that market and attract tourists from the destinations that they are accustomed to going to, so they contracted with Accor a big French company with properties all over the world, that planned to market it as at least a 4 star hotel, 5 if the owners did the additional upgrading that Accor requested. Accor only had 2 years, and before their plans had the chance to come to fruition, the owners signed with another company, one that promised to immediately fill the hotel.
Which that company did by signing contracts with a number of tour operators, many of them bringing German clients. To get those clients, the wealthy Germans go to Bavaro and other resorts on south coast, not to the north coast, the hotel went all-inclusive with rock bottom prices, so low that it was necessary to have about 100% occupancy to even break even.
Because prices were so low, service was bare minimum and major maintenance was non-existent. And the businesses in town benefitted not at all.
Having had that experience, I will continue to believe that a more upscale type of tourist, one that will pay more and spend more, is good for tourism. Even though being on a fixed income, it does make it more difficult.
I can also recall arriving in Samana in 1986, a much different Samana than exists today. Yes, there is much to be said for the way things were, and certainly a dollar went much further than it does today. But, we bought our meat in the farmers market, to go to Santo Domingo met a long ride on a very crowded yellow school bus, to get a decent dentist we had to go to San Francisco de Macoris and for doctors for anything but the common cold, to Santo Domingo. The closest supermarket was San Francisco de Macoris, more than 2 hours away, and the selection of products available was much, much smaller than we have today.
To get progress, you do pay a price. And since I can't do anything to turn back the clock, even if I wanted to, or change the direction that tourism is taking in the DR, rants by Batich and others just go in one ear and out the other.
Besides, I think Batich is kicking the wrong horse. I think the merchants, or those that have competition, are keeping prices low in order to be competitive. But the taxes, customs fees, etc., that the government is collecting have been increasing steadily. But I can't do anything about that, either.