I don't like this idea for many reasons. Any attempts to limit access to those with a cedula or some sort of authentic credentials will harm the quality of the website and the information contained therein. I discovered dr1.com through Junot Diaz. I think he would be excluded from this new message board service and by the sound of it many supporters of this idea would think that would be a good thing.
To them, Junot Diaz's foreign residence, dilutes his authority. That is, in my humble opinion, absurd. Likewise, my proud Dominican born and bred wife would be excluded, along with a multitude of other equally qualified folks. To the supporters of this proposal, the fresh-off-the-boat Albertan emigre with six months under her belt is somehow more qualified that Junot Diaz...That's just silly.
This is the internet, the wild west of information. Anyone who has frequented this site for any length of time and who is not a complete idiot, knows that the credo to follow here is 'Reader Beware.' There are many trolls lurking here and negativity is rife. So consider the information carefully. Consider who is saying it, how they are saying it, whether what they are saying is supported by independent fact, etc. If you don't do that, you get what you deserve.
The fact is the Dominican Republic has a huge diaspora and any website, in English, about the Dominican Republic, is by definition going to attract those in the diaspora. If a cedula carrying Dominican forum is what is desired, my advice is to learn Spanish very well because there are no doubt countless such sites already in existence, in the DR, on .do domains, by Dominicans, for Dominicans.
My two cents, leave dr1.com alone.